
A Faithful Amish Return
Failed to add items
Add to Cart failed.
Add to Wish List failed.
Remove from wishlist failed.
Adding to library failed
Follow podcast failed
Unfollow podcast failed
$0.00 for first 30 days
Buy for $4.99
No default payment method selected.
We are sorry. We are not allowed to sell this product with the selected payment method
-
Narrated by:
-
Virtual Voice
-
By:
-
Sadie Weaver

This title uses virtual voice narration
About this listen
He walked away once. Can she trust him to stay… and will she risk her heart again?
When Elijah Stoltzfus returns to Lancaster County, he’s determined to make amends and help his family. But for schoolteacher Sarah Hochstetler, his return stirs old doubts. She swore she’d never risk her heart again—especially on a man who left her behind.
As they work together to help his struggling niece, Sarah sees a different man than the angry boy who left—patient, steady, and kind. But as the community’s whispers grow louder and trust proves fragile, believing in Eli could cost Sarah everything she’s worked for.
Now, they must decide: hold on to the safety of past friendship or risk everything for a future built on faith… and love.
A heartwarming Amish romance about a bishop’s prodigal son, a cautious teacher, and finding your way home.
People who viewed this also viewed...
-
Captivating Amish Hearts Collection
- By: Amelia Yoder
- Narrated by: Virtual Voice
- Length: 18 hrs and 57 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Uncover the captivating world of faith, love, and hope through the powerful, wholesome Christian stories by Amelia Yoder —where every page inspires, uplifts, and transforms. Tremendous value at this low price. For a limited time only! Get your coffee ready while you step into the ways of the Amish and enjoy the journey that true love brings. This collection includes: Amanda’s Amish Wedding - Always a bride, never a wife… will Amanda finally become a frau this summer? Nurturing Amish Love - He opened his eyes to see her sitting in the corner watching over him like an angel. An Amish ...
By: Amelia Yoder
-
A Chance Encounter (Hearts of Harmony Hill Book One)
- An Amish Romance
- By: Sylvia Price
- Narrated by: Virtual Voice
- Length: 2 hrs and 55 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
In the tranquil Amish community of Harmony Hill, Eleanor Stoltzfus, a kind-hearted young woman deeply devoted to her Amish faith and family, has always believed her future lies within the simple rhythms of her community. But when Ethan Abbott, a modern Englischer architect, finds himself stranded near her family farm, their worlds collide in unexpected ways. As Eleanor helps Ethan navigate his stay in Lancaster County, a bond begins to form between them, defying the cultural and religious boundaries that separate them. With each passing day, they must face the growing tension between ...
By: Sylvia Price
-
Amish Promises
- Neighbors of Lancaster County
- By: Leslie Gould
- Narrated by: Stina Nielsen
- Length: 13 hrs and 12 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
When Joel and Shani Beck arrive at their new home on Juneberry Lane in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, they're looking for peace. Joel's recently returned from Iraq and is recuperating, and Shani is just happy to have her family back together. They can't imagine any trouble with their Amish neighbors, the Lehmans, but things get off to a rocky start when their son accidently hurts Simon, one of the Lehman boys.
-
-
The Most Awesome Book
- By betty on 05-24-15
By: Leslie Gould
-
Secrets of Willow Springs Trilogy
- Amish Mystery Series - Three Novels in One Volume
- By: Tracy Fredrychowski
- Narrated by: Virtual Voice
- Length: 17 hrs and 31 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
In this quiet Amish community, a decades-old secret will put one family’s faith to the ultimate test. Book 1 - Her family’s hidden secret could destroy her. Will Forgiveness set her future free? Emma Byler can’t wait for her sixteenth birthday and to experience a taste of freedom. With her Amish Rumspringa relaxing some of her usual restrictions, she’s desperate to spend time with a special boy. But she fears tensions at home and her father’s increasingly short temper could make him pull back the reins. Book 2 - Can secrets from the past be forgiven in this Amish family drama ...
-
-
Great Books
- By Nicole on 06-23-25
-
Beneath the Simple Sky
- An Amish Romance
- By: Grace Given
- Narrated by: Virtual Voice
- Length: 2 hrs and 32 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
When secrets are sought, truth finds a way into the hardest heart. Tom Craven wants scandal. As editor of the Happy Creek Sentinel, he sends cynical journalist Henry Broderick to live among the Amish of Happy Creek for a month, demanding dark stories that will sell papers. Meanwhile, Amethyst Schlappach's heart aches with uncertainty. Though she and Reuben Oyer shared one beautiful kiss, his distance since has left her wondering if his feelings were genuine. When Henry arrives to stay at her family's house, tensions rise as Reuben's jealousy awakens him to what truly matters. As Henry ...
-
-
Amish romance, indeed
- By Candi on 04-15-25
By: Grace Given
-
The Amish Bishop's Boppli
- By: Amelia Yoder
- Narrated by: Virtual Voice
- Length: 1 hr and 51 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Growing a boppli can be a blessing, but it can also be a recipe for burnout. Two years after being ordained as the new bishop of their community, Samuel and his wife Eve are still enjoying the freedom of being a newlywed couple. Their marriage began with some rocky roads, but now that they figured out how to manage it all, day-to-day chores and work seem comfortable. That is until they receive some life-changing news. Eve soon finds a new challenge knocking at their door. This is by far the hardest thing she has ever had to endure. She never imagined going through it on her own. She often ...
By: Amelia Yoder
-
Captivating Amish Hearts Collection
- By: Amelia Yoder
- Narrated by: Virtual Voice
- Length: 18 hrs and 57 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Uncover the captivating world of faith, love, and hope through the powerful, wholesome Christian stories by Amelia Yoder —where every page inspires, uplifts, and transforms. Tremendous value at this low price. For a limited time only! Get your coffee ready while you step into the ways of the Amish and enjoy the journey that true love brings. This collection includes: Amanda’s Amish Wedding - Always a bride, never a wife… will Amanda finally become a frau this summer? Nurturing Amish Love - He opened his eyes to see her sitting in the corner watching over him like an angel. An Amish ...
By: Amelia Yoder
-
A Chance Encounter (Hearts of Harmony Hill Book One)
- An Amish Romance
- By: Sylvia Price
- Narrated by: Virtual Voice
- Length: 2 hrs and 55 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
In the tranquil Amish community of Harmony Hill, Eleanor Stoltzfus, a kind-hearted young woman deeply devoted to her Amish faith and family, has always believed her future lies within the simple rhythms of her community. But when Ethan Abbott, a modern Englischer architect, finds himself stranded near her family farm, their worlds collide in unexpected ways. As Eleanor helps Ethan navigate his stay in Lancaster County, a bond begins to form between them, defying the cultural and religious boundaries that separate them. With each passing day, they must face the growing tension between ...
By: Sylvia Price
-
Amish Promises
- Neighbors of Lancaster County
- By: Leslie Gould
- Narrated by: Stina Nielsen
- Length: 13 hrs and 12 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
When Joel and Shani Beck arrive at their new home on Juneberry Lane in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, they're looking for peace. Joel's recently returned from Iraq and is recuperating, and Shani is just happy to have her family back together. They can't imagine any trouble with their Amish neighbors, the Lehmans, but things get off to a rocky start when their son accidently hurts Simon, one of the Lehman boys.
-
-
The Most Awesome Book
- By betty on 05-24-15
By: Leslie Gould
-
Secrets of Willow Springs Trilogy
- Amish Mystery Series - Three Novels in One Volume
- By: Tracy Fredrychowski
- Narrated by: Virtual Voice
- Length: 17 hrs and 31 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
In this quiet Amish community, a decades-old secret will put one family’s faith to the ultimate test. Book 1 - Her family’s hidden secret could destroy her. Will Forgiveness set her future free? Emma Byler can’t wait for her sixteenth birthday and to experience a taste of freedom. With her Amish Rumspringa relaxing some of her usual restrictions, she’s desperate to spend time with a special boy. But she fears tensions at home and her father’s increasingly short temper could make him pull back the reins. Book 2 - Can secrets from the past be forgiven in this Amish family drama ...
-
-
Great Books
- By Nicole on 06-23-25
-
Beneath the Simple Sky
- An Amish Romance
- By: Grace Given
- Narrated by: Virtual Voice
- Length: 2 hrs and 32 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
When secrets are sought, truth finds a way into the hardest heart. Tom Craven wants scandal. As editor of the Happy Creek Sentinel, he sends cynical journalist Henry Broderick to live among the Amish of Happy Creek for a month, demanding dark stories that will sell papers. Meanwhile, Amethyst Schlappach's heart aches with uncertainty. Though she and Reuben Oyer shared one beautiful kiss, his distance since has left her wondering if his feelings were genuine. When Henry arrives to stay at her family's house, tensions rise as Reuben's jealousy awakens him to what truly matters. As Henry ...
-
-
Amish romance, indeed
- By Candi on 04-15-25
By: Grace Given
-
The Amish Bishop's Boppli
- By: Amelia Yoder
- Narrated by: Virtual Voice
- Length: 1 hr and 51 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Growing a boppli can be a blessing, but it can also be a recipe for burnout. Two years after being ordained as the new bishop of their community, Samuel and his wife Eve are still enjoying the freedom of being a newlywed couple. Their marriage began with some rocky roads, but now that they figured out how to manage it all, day-to-day chores and work seem comfortable. That is until they receive some life-changing news. Eve soon finds a new challenge knocking at their door. This is by far the hardest thing she has ever had to endure. She never imagined going through it on her own. She often ...
By: Amelia Yoder