Anthony Conlin is a forty-one year old workaholic in love with his twenty-nine year old neighbor, Reece Whitmore, who is too handsome for his own good. He longs for Reece to the point of obsession but doesn’t think he stands a chance because of their age difference, his graying hair, and a less-than rock-hard physique.

When his friend Raul urges Anthony to try the matching services he’s used in the past to great result, Anthony refuses because of his crush on Reece. But Raul has something up his sleeve to make certain Anthony and Reece finally get together.

A charity auction sets the stage and rolls into motion a night Anthony and Reece will never forget.

Carly Kimball, columnist for the popular magazine Chit Chat Weekly, is going undercover to reveal the truth behind the mysterious matchmaking services of Eternal Affection. She’ll infiltrate the luxury Grand Turk Malabann resort where many of the guests there have used Eternal Affection. But she’s in for an even bigger shock when she comes in contact with a man from her past, Quinn Alfasi, who she shared one passionate night with back in college.

Quinn never thought he’d see Carly again, and now six years later she’s walked back into his life. He’ll do whatever he has to in order to expose her as a liar and a fraud. But then his best friend Woody shows an interest. He won’t allow her to fall for Woody’s charms even if he has to team up with his Lothario best friend to claim Carly as his own.