storyline is awesome!!

the narration was choppy and hard to follow sometimes.. almost made it hard to finish at one point. then the curiosity of the storyline took over more towards the end.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Pleasantly Surprised

That's not to say I expected it to be bad, but I didn't expect the variety in the tales. Each story even though they surround the same character have similarities to each other but also quite distinct changing I guess sub-genre from one tale to the next. I'd actually love more exploring the cosmology of her world.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Lovely surprise

I thought I was getting a romance novel so I was at first thinking this was not living up to expectations. But, I kept finding myself smiling, literally and frequently, at the clever word choices of the writer.

When I realized it was not a romance, at least not like I was thinking, I began to wonder what it was, genre-wise, and I’m still not quite sure. Kind of a fantasy-historical fiction-biography-memoir.

The narrator had a wide range of voices and emotional expression. Well done.

The main character is the strongest, yet realistic, female lead I’ve seen in a long time. A character with single mindedness, skill and flaws.

There are twists in the stories that I appreciated. Yes, I said “stories”. If you don’t realize that this is like different chapters in someone’s life versus one plot line with a single crisis and resolution, you too may be lost like I was and miss the elegance at first. But the ending was perfect.

This is the first review I’ve written (that I remember) and I just felt like this book deserved my time. I would have given it 4 1/2 stars, but I don’t know how. 4 is not enough. I didn’t do 5, because it took me awhile to catch on, but that might just be me.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

MUCH better chapter order at end of my review

Real quick note here: 1934 sci-fi with a female protagonist who's a leader, warrior, and solos most of her content. These stories, written preWW2, is mind blowing and I'm willing to overlook the outdated female tropes because of the time they were written in.

I agree with the professional critics that these stories' subject matter have strong links to H.P. Lovecraft with demons, aliens, and shady magicians. The difference is that when I read Lovecraft, I feel like I'm watching a black and white murder mystery. As opposed to Moore, it feels more like watching Heavy Metal (1981 movie).

=== Better chapter order
My only complaint is that, according to character development, the current chapter order makes the protagonist seem indecisive and stupid. I highly recommend instead going chapters: 10, 9, 1-6, 7, then 8. Also, mentally alter the ending to chapter 8 so she accepts the dark god's offer.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Jirel of Joiry is a great character

I really like the character of Jirel of Joiry. She is such a bad-ass, and this is from a time when hardly anyone was writing female heroes, and no one was writing them as hardcore as C.L. Moore wrote Jirel.
Much respect to C. L. Moore to not only to write SFF when no women were writing for this genre and then take it a step further by creating a female sword & sorcery protagonist when no one else - except Robert E. Howard - was writing of heroines.
All that said, not to mention I enjoy descriptive writing, but Moore does run-on quite a bit when describing the other worldly dimensions that Jirel ventures into, to the point I couldn't help but skip over.
Still, I loved Jirel so much that I would love to read more of her adventures.

Gabrielle de Cuin reading was so well done that I'll seek out other books that she performs.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

I didn’t like the book, but somehow I really did like it.

When I first started the book I didn’t like it but I kept listening anyway. I thought the book was quite racist. The way they emphasized the whiteness of the heroin. Also the villains were black or thru some foul blackness. Near the end of the book, I decided my review would be: The Happy Hooker, played by Zena the warrior princess, does Indiana Jones, Harry Potter, and Captain Kirk on Star Trek...... Then I heard the written date, and copyright dates. I was blown away. That info should be put up front. For that time period this book was way ahead of it’s time. The Harlequin descriptions, I’m sure, were to attract female readers to Sci-Fi. The racist innuendos were appropriate for the time. After hearing the details of the time period, I decided this was a very good book. It kept me listening even tho I didn’t like it, but somehow I really did like it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Great stuff!

Dreamlike and imaginative sword and sorcery. C. L. Moore and Robert E. Howard remain two of the most readable pulp writers of the Weird Tales era. The stories are well plotted and sometimes verge on the surreal. The first two stories are closely connected and remind me of The Nightland by William Hope Hodgson. Well read. Recommended.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Not horrible but not my preference

Old fantasy and use of rhetoric. Last short story was the best. Found it to be bland

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Female sword & sorcery from the 1930's

C L Moore's Black God's Kiss is a series of sword and sorcery tales, newly recognized at the time as a distinct genre, but with a female protagonist written in the 1930's. The tales are located in France in a medieval setting, with Jorel as the leader of some vague group, with hostilities seemingly ongoing all the time. She always seems to find herself in some sort of pickle which involves supernatural locales and pits her against strong magic, although she possesses no magical abilities herself. The last story in this collection is a crossover tale with another Moore character, Northwest Smith.

Each tale is relatively short as was the style of this type of pulp fiction for its time. There's little if any background on how Jorel came by her swordsmanship ability, nor how she came to be the top dog (other than by her superior sword play). Interestingly, while she typically faces other females with magical abilities as her foes, she seems to have avoided enlisting any other females in her fighting militia.

The narration is well done with moderate character distinction. Pacing is a bit on the slow side.

Note: there are two entries for Black God's Kiss. This one is the full collection of five Jorel tales, plus the crossover tale, while the shorter offering is simply, the short story entitled Black God's Kiss.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

Kiss & Tell

I found this book repetitive and had difficulty sympathizing with main character. I wouldn't recommend this novel, nor would I advise anyone against reading it. It's like eating air popped popcorn with seasoning.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!