Some decent analysis if you can stay awake

The first challenge that I had with this book was making it past the almost two hours of the author telling me what he was GOING to talk about before actually getting to the content in earnest. The analysis of each work feels a bit stretched. Reminds me of when I was in college and tried to BS my way through a essay by applying small amounts of theory and stretching them in an effort to substantiate my position. The narrator is un-enthused which adds to the pain. Especially grating is the attempt to speak with an Austrian accent when quoting Freud. All in all there are some worthwhile nuggets, but the work as a whole left me feeling 'MEH'

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Dry but essential, well presented

This is a well written but very dry book, but it takes its subject deservedly seriously. Refreshing.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Like a bad term paper! Get"Shock Value" Instead.

What disappointed you about Dark Directions?

This is written like a poorly done term paper or lecture by a professor that does not really know his material but has read other's reviews of the films and feels he is entitled to give his opinions anyway.

Phillips spends less than 20 minutes on "Halloween", a movie that changed horror forever (by bringing the horror into a regular neighborhood instead of requiring the characters to go to the haunted house on the hill, the deserted motel in the middle of nowhere, etc), yet Carpenter is listed as one of the 3 directors that will be covered in the book. You advertise that you are going to discuss a director, and his most famous work is given mere minutes in such a rambling book.

The premise here is not a knowledgeable review of the works, but instead an author giving his psychoanalytical review of the films, which you get the feeling he has read reviews about but not actually seen. I could not get over how poorly done and vague it was while supposedly focusing on just 3 directors and their works.

I read "Shock Value" after reading this and it did a much better job of covering the material "Dark Directions" claimed it would.

What do you think your next listen will be?

My next listen after this was "Shock Value". A much better attempt at similar material. From there I moved on to Sherry Lansing's "Leading Lady".

What did you like about the performance? What did you dislike?

I gave 3 points to the performance for being clear, loud enough, and a voice somewhat appropriate to the material. I am finding some books are not produced loud enough to play over speakers or even headphones with enough volume. I have nice speakers, but they can only amplify what they are given.

You didn’t love this book... but did it have any redeeming qualities?

I did not find anything redeeming in the book. It was worse than most college essays. I am guessing this was written by a professor or someone like that he accepted a grant to write about the genre but didn't actually know the genre. I had a film studies professor who thought "Goodfellas" was a fictional story directed by Michael Scorsese. MICHAEL?!? When debated about such things, he held to his being an expert.... an expert that could have read the DVD dust cover and been more informed. Reading this book felt very much like being back in that class.

Any additional comments?

Read "Shock Value" if you want to get the material promised and save yourself the cost and time I invested in this book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!