Amazing just simply outstanding

I couldn't stop listening. I started reading the book a few years back, but the book disappeared from the duty desk.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Difficult to review

I have no problem with the writing in this book. It is written well. The only thing I do not like about the book is sometimes in flashbacks, the transition is not clear enough. This may have been intentional due to the nature of the narrator, but it still made it difficult to follow.

Book ratings are subjective. Objectively, this is an excellent book. It delves well into what happens to people in war. I have not experienced it myself, but it feels authentic. What I have seen from the outside of soldiers that have served in wars, it seems realistic.

And that is my SUBJECTIVE reason for giving this book 2 stars. Objectively, I would probably give this 4 stars, subjectively... the subject matter is too foreign to me, to odd, and to... real. I tend to read/listen for escapism. This book is brutal reality, and just... not MY type of book.

So take this as a SUBJECTIVE opinion, and don't ignore this book if it is your type of book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

psychological action romance.

loved this book. I'm sure you could never understand what anyone who has been thru a war goes thru. this title helps paint a picture of not only the physical struggle( bombs, bullets, and disease) but also the psychological battles people have to face during and after a war. losing loved ones, adjusting to any sort of normal life after. the author has used a theater of sci fi future war and by doing so hooked me from the start.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great Story Marred by Poor Performance

I think fans of science fiction--and in particular, military scifi--deserve accurate pronounciation of terms. It is "core-man," NOT "cores-man," and yes, I know how it's spelled. The "s", just like the "p" is silent. There were other mispronounciations as well, but this one just screamed out at me every time I heard it. There are no acceptable excuses. I don't blame the reader, who in every other regard did a fine job. No, I blame the producer and the director. Take some care and pride in your work. I paid good money for this audiobook. I deserve the words to be pronounced correctly.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

12 people found this helpful

A Truly Engaging Story

This book really surprised me, and once the story had me I couldn't put it down (well, pause it I suppose). The story was excellent, the characterization superb, and the portrayal of the conflict very realistic. It reminded me very much of my first reading of Micheal Herr's Dispatches. The narration was spot on, and perfectly in-tune with the personalities in the story. Probably one of my best purchases thus far on Audible.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

Excellent book

I enjoyed this book. It is a grimy / dirt military adventure with Strong characters and excellent writing. The author will move to the upper portion on my list.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

A military sci-fi that isn't sci-fi at all

It is a military sci-fi that doesn't include weapon-porn (so we are not subjected to what size rounds fit in which type of gun, nor how many revolutions ammunition might make in a gun barrel, or the armour penetration per inch by weapon type, etc). I like military-ish fiction that doesn't include gun/military enthusiasts' fantasies, so this book fit the bill for me.

Sure, some of the military stuff was glossed over, and some of the sci-fi was glossed over... and really, it wasn't all that sci-fi-y. It's almost like a straight up "look, I survived an atrocious war even though I came out scarred" novel. There was nothing in it that is outside the current realm of possibility: although some of the tech might not actually exist yet, the theories behind the tech does.

But the book isn't really even about war, it's about the people impacted by war...

The main character isn't a soldier. And that means we get to see a very long war from an alternative point of view. I also think it allowed Oscar to be better written, and more humanized than he would have been if he was a proper soldier. i.e. there was no real harm in him being high as a kite in the midst of battle since he wasn't really supposed to be there anyway.

The story is actually one of growth and maturity: it's the maturation of one man - because of, or in spite of, a horrendous war background. There is some (not overly moralistic) message about how war scars people psychologically, and how our veterans may not receive the respect and help they require after returning... particularly in circumstances where the "war" has slipped from the front page.

The narration is fine. Surprisingly, there is not much gore or swearing, and there is no detailed sex. The story is wrapped up completely at the end.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

7 people found this helpful

Gritty

Story was harsh, but compelling. Reader needs to learn that corpsman is pronounced "koorman". This book was "credit worthy" if you want a slightly future gritty war story.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Best of Audible SFF, July 2011

In her review for Bull Spec #6, C.D. Covington called Germline ???equal parts The Forever War and Hammer???s Slammers??? and that???s pretty high praise. The book doesn???t have the star-spanning scope of Joe Haldeman???s The Forever War, and it doesn???t have the attention to detail of Hammer???s Slammers. But neither of these is the point. The novel is a first person foray into a future war through the eyes of an increasingly strung-out failed journalist. There is no lengthy exposition of how the battle suits work, what the weapons or countryside look like, or, in fact, lengthy exposition at all. There are missteps (particularly in some of the major transitions) and the book doesn???t achieve perfection, but there???s just something to it: something which vaguely recalls Vonnegut, or even Kerouac, in its bouncing, drug-blurred narrative. Publishers Weekly name-checks ???Remarque, Willi Heinrich, and especially Michael Herr??? but these names don???t mean much to me (though a quick trip to Wikipedia was quite informative). At a brisk 9 hours, very well-cast with Corren???s narration, it was exactly the summer change-up I needed from the 40-50 hour epics of George R.R. Martin. (Which I enjoyed immensely in that mode, but there???s a certain discount factor when comparing books of 9 and 50 hours!)

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Scifi war for adults

The future of war on earth is shitty. Shitty reasons, shitty conditions. This book is a good counterbalance to scifi war books that are just a grand adventure (which I also enjoy). Worth your time.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful