Beautifully written, perfectly narrated

I first read this novel years go when it was originally called Women in Black and enjoyed it. As a film version has just come out I listened to the audio book to refresh my memory and enjoyed it even more the second time around. Most women will be familiar with the helpful Ladies in Black in the fashion sections of big department stores all over the world, although sadly nowadays they are a disappearing breed.

If you enjoy character portraits, this could be a rewarding book for you, with wit and humour and a selection of people from differing backgrounds set in Sydney, Australia in the late 1950's. Outstanding for me were Magda and Stefan, displaced refugees from war torn Europe, getting re-settled happily in a new country, while keeping alive their own culture and group of friends. I laughed and admired Magda's virtual soliloquy as she greets and welcomes her guests, I could picture the happy chaos so well, and also later the description of all the customers and the atmosphere of the traditional January Sales.

It is a beautifully written novel, the story flows, the characters are drawn perfectly, the dialogue is convincing, nothing grates and you feel empathy in different ways for each of the characters.

The narration by Deirdre Rubenstein is top-notch, every character voice rings true to the writer's intent and the whole experience was pleasure. This is not my usual reading fare, but recommend it gladly to those who will take it as intended, a delightful slice of life, typical of the era and a thoughtful gentle look at a group of women and their interactions with each other over a short time in their lives.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Good book wonderful narration

Such an interesting, unusual book. I was fascinated by the outstanding narration which brought the story to life

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

I loved this charming story!!

I loved that this was about good, interesting, descent people who all deserved the best in life and were able to find it. It's so refreshing to read such a well written, charming, clean, happy story.
Wonderful narration!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Should have just watched the movie.

I read this book in anticipation of seeing the movie. I had hoped for a complex plot, rich characters, Sydney landscapes, fifties nostalgia and a good dose of humour. But the novel for me failed to achieve these goals. While we get a sense that these ladies have had their fair share of misfortune and hardships in the past, it seems too easy, and predictable, to grant all the characters a simple happy ending. Even the return of Frank, his departure being the only palpable tension in the novel, was such an anticlimax. Perhaps I missed the humour in it. At best an easy light read , possibly while travelling on the ferry to Manly.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!