The Public Service vs The Individual

Would you consider the audio edition of Light Shining in the Forest to be better than the print version?

I haven't read this book, I have only listened to it.

Has Light Shining in the Forest turned you off from other books in this genre?

I don't think it is very easy to slip this book into a genre.The story is horrible, macabre, bizarre - in the class of weird that I put M J Hayder - but it is not only that. It is more; and more important.The motif of unaccompained children being taken by someone that they know, rather than a stranger is very, very unsettling. All the more so when the listener realises the reason behind the kidnappings. What happens to the children is not dealt with in any detail, and if it were, it would be unbearable. BUT - This book is written by a man who clearly understands the machinations of the Public Service, in particular, its awful failings and bureaucracies. He very cleverly juxtaposes these with what is happening to the kidnapped children and how The System fails them. And fails them very badly.He also shows how the system, being amoral, can never be changed nor overcome by an individual; and so, in the greatest irony of all, the listener discovers that Norman, the Children's Czar without a job but who cannot be removed from his public service post until he transgresses the public service codes, Norman then enters that other massive and amoral bureaucracy - the Roman Catholic Church!

Which character – as performed by David Timson – was your favorite?

No favourites, I just found it very easy to follow the book because of the clarity of David Timson's characterisations

If you could rename Light Shining in the Forest, what would you call it?

No Picnic For Teddy Bears

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Gripping

What did you love best about Light Shining in the Forest?

Paul Torday creates fabulous characters & develops them beautifully.

Who was your favorite character and why?

Norman for some strange reason is my favourite character. He finds himself in this book & is willing to not look away when confronted with difficult situations.

Which character – as performed by David Timson – was your favorite?

Willy was well performed by David Timson, as were all the characters.

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

I didn't want to stop reading. I read it in 2 days & if I could, would've read non-stop.

Any additional comments?

I adored Paul Torday's "Salmon Fishing in the Yemen" & "The Irresistible Inheritance of Wilberforce".

This has a more traditional "who dunnit" storyline, the other two are more in a catagory all of their own.

But we do find out early on what part various characters play & are just holding our breath to find out whether the other characters catch up to our knowledge.

It certainly falls into a more traditional category such as mystery, suspense or thriller, but as usual with Paul Torday this book has a fascinating, gripping quality that makes you want to read on.

If you're looking for something more literary go to "Salmon Fishing" (you'll be delightedly surprised) & "Wilberforce", but this is another good work from Torday & if you've enjoyed his previous work & like his style, well this certainly carries his own flair but I wouldn't rank it as "literary fiction" as his other books I've mentioned. Still a great read. And coming from someone who never reads mystery, thriller or suspense novels that is something.

Narrator is easy to listen to - does a good job with the book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!