interesting

It was very indepth about the Stuarts and William of Orange. There weren't very many links to America, it was more focused on England.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Loved it, but be prepared

The book is a marvelous telling of Charles II, James II, William of Orange, and parliamentary v royalty struggles. Eventually, the former wins. The narrator is superb, really. My caution is that the author gives an account that is too detailed, e.g., William spends late spring to early autumn on the continent for most of the 1690s. You learn the exact months he is there for all 7 or 8 years, which are the same months for most of those years. You learn the expenditures of the Crown and Parliament in precise numbers for lots of items, e.g. 605,322 for this, 42,317 for that, 1,189,754 for something else. So, the book is longer than one needs to learn the history non-historians want to know. Sill, it isn't hard to tolerate this detail. But, don't be surprised.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

good, not great

This book comes in two parts, the first 40% of so is the necessary background information for understanding the "Glorious Revolution" & its immediate aftermath, the context. The remaining 60% is the story of the run-up to the revolution under James II, the conquest, and the aftermath. The work is well narrated. However, the first portion is a jumble, organizationally, and the previous Audible reviewer who noted that having a good understanding of the history from other sources is necessary to understand this part of the book, was right on target. I do have that background, and it helped immensely. I should say that the author does a good job on vignettes & small interpretative sections here, but jumps around a bit too much and needed an editor to insert thesis statements here & there.

The 60% that is actually about the Glorious Revolution (which some pundit remarked was "neither glorious nor a revolution") is very well done. It is worth getting the book to listen to this portion. The author's history is good here, the narrative drive moves you along, and this part of the book has ample amounts of thesis statements & good organization. The author's interpretations of the events, events that were critical to the future evolution of the UK and North America, is good.

I highly recommend the book for the last 60%.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

9 people found this helpful

ambitious topic, well executed

If you could sum up Our First Revolution in three words, what would they be?

A fine account of the half century leading up to the Glorious Revolution and the denouement afterwards. A bit undisciplined in its wide ranging focus and miscellany of themes. At times I felt the author was including his research even if it didn't quite fit in the book. However, the importance of the book's subject and its grand ambition makes up for such flaws.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

One of the finest histories, superb performance

Brilliant history filled with fascinating characters. Insights into the Stuart kings, Churchill and William of Orange are fascinating. At the end Barone ties it all up and tells us why it matters. Hoye's performance has exactly the right tone and pacing. One of my favorite repeat listens.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Important, yet not Widely Known

This revolution before the American Revolution seems to have been important in shaping the American identity and probably in shaping the American Revolution.

I was previously unaware of the "The Glorious Revolution". Learning about it shed light on much of American politics, especially American religious politics. This book gave me a new appreciation of William of Orange. More importantly it gave me a new appreciation for the origins of anti-catholic sentiment, which always seemed a little, well un-American.

Finally, this book reinforced the idea that a non-trivial part of what America great was the ability to forge more or less real religious tolerance. In the last 20 years it seems that there has been a noticeable erosion of religious tolerance. I hope this is a temporary fad and not a trend, and wish that I could persuade more of neighbors of the importance of this issue.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Excellent Recap of a Forgotten Event

This is submitted just as an observation from the previous review which gave this book a somewhat undeserved low rating. It is correct that the narrative covers a confusing and contradictory event in history, but I found its approach creating a straight forward,even balanced, and most importantly, an interesting account all the same.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

11 people found this helpful

Fascinating history

A fascinating and detailed account of a little known, but very important chapter in both British and American history.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Superb Book

Would you listen to Our First Revolution again? Why?

Yes. Barone relates a period of English history that profoundly influenced the American founders. I don't understand those who criticize either the book or the narrator. Yes, it's a complicated story. But the careful reader will be rewarded, and the American reader will understand our founding much better. Highly recommended.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Not a Real Historian

I don't have a lot to say because I didn't finish the book, and I'll be the first to admit that, because of that, you shouldn't go on my opinion alone on this one.

But I did want to issue a buyer beware: Michael Barone is not a real historian but a Fox News hack--ok, he also wrote for US News). Does that mean he's not qualified to write a history book? Not necessarily. But in the short part of the book I listened to (enough to make me go "who is this author anyway" and then to wiki him), it was clear that this is a book looking to draw broad, simplistic, moralistic conclusions from history. It's intended to show us where our freedom comes from and why America is the greatest nation on Earth, etc.

Again, that doesn't mean the book is worthless, but there are plenty of excellent books out there on 17th century English history. Unfortunately, none on audible at the moment.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful