Hit this one out of the park

I loved this book. It was entertaining and informative. The characters were interesting and realistic. Will read more in the series.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Meskimen inhabits Dupré, and Bowen's whole world

I've liked the Peter Bowen Montana mysteries for a long time, but these new recordings by Jim Meskimen outdo the old ones by a long long mile. Meskimen 's reading is head and shoulders better than the earlier versions—he allows us to see how good the writing is in these plain prairie tales, complicated by mystical interruptions from the venerable Benetsee. Bowen's humour comes shining through here, and so does the genuine clean air of that Montana landscape. Very highly recommended.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Good, but read after the first book!

This is another great Gabriel Du Pré mystery. It is a continuation of the first volume, with the same characters: Benettsee the seer/shaman, Booger Tom, Madeleine the girlfriend, and his daughters who adore him.

This book starts out in Washington, DC, where Gabriel Du Pré has come to perform his fiddling music which emerges from his Indian/French heritage. He is anxious to return to Montana where he feels at home on the land, in his comfortable routines, but he has not even left yet when the first murder occurs. The rest of the story weaves in interesting Indian lore, showing the marvelously simple connections to what he feels makes his life worth living.

BUT WARNING to reader: read previous book first, unless you don't mind that the author has included one line of explanation about Du Pré's past that is a complete spoiler for the first mystery. I know that authors often do this, by way of letting a new reader know what has occurred in the past. But if you happen to read one out of order, it can be very discouraging to realize that you probably won't feel like reading the one you missed.

Both books are good, extremely interesting with the lore of the west, the French/Indian heritage and the wonderful characters that people these stories. the narration is very good in both.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Is this Unabridged?

The amount of jumping around combined with the shortness of this book makes me wonder if it was an abridged version. Hard to follow. Seemed incomplete. I was disappointed as I really enjoyed the previous book in this series.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Still loving the series

Love all the characters. Love the descriptions of the terrain. Story was gripping. Love the magic.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

story decent, narration lackluster

enjoyed the story, and the background on the tribal practices, even tho there was a fair bit of "woo-woo" in how many clues were just "known". handy device for moving the plot forward without having to come up with plausible means for the lead to find out the info. narration was forgettable, with a nber of mispronunciations and no attempt at authentic accents. much preferred Christopher lane, who did the earlier books.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Really like this series, except with this narrator

Love this series and the characters,. Just wish Christopher Lane narrated all of them, he really brings characters to life and make them distinctive.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

What a specimen

Another great listen. Can't wait to start the next one. Great voices from the reader.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great story, wrong narrator

Lets get right to it. In the previous recordings, which were done out of sequence, the narrator was fantastic, I mean fantastic. Gabriel speaks french as well as english, he is part Canadian Cree, the first narrator did the accent perfectly, it was so entertaining and added a great amount to the experience of the book. Let me state that given the right assignment this narrator would be great, he does try very hard, and is not bad at his craft, it is that this is the wrong book for him. Very often he mispronounces the french and even the native use of language, it took some of the beauty of the writing style of this author and flushed it down the toilet.
With all of this talk about the narrator said the story is still a good one and one, the blending of Gabriel's culture, native, french, rural west is something I enjoyed a great deal, it is just that with this narrator it sucked a lot of the fun out of the audio version.
Great story wrong narrator
recommended, with hope that the original narrator is brought back.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

The difference between reading & performing

The Gabriel Du Pre' mystery series by Peter Bowen are my favorite books. They are written with a lot of dialect, and have a lot of mystique in them. Now we finally have some more of them in audio, but we no longer have the gifted Christopher Lane reading them. Lane voiced Gabriel Du Pre' with Coyote French gutturals and western twang, creating a truly life-like character in all dimensions.

Mr. Meskimen reads the book adequately, but he does not have the acting ability or the vocal range to bring the characters alive.

Du Pre' is a Montana brand inspector that drives too fast, drinks too much, dances when he can, and fiddles to the happy crowds in Toussaint's lone bar, as well as at other gatherings. He lives in sin with the lovely Madeline, and they both have kids and grandkids. In the case of Du Pre', it's a passle of grandkids, as one of his two daughters decided to make up for her mother's early death by giving her papa a big family to love. The other daughter is a genius, off doing big things.

I tell you these things because you might not learn all of them in this book, and it is important that you know that Du Pre' takes no crap from anybody. Him, he's got good friends, and sometimes he figures things out, just because something doesn't look right. Meanwhile he is proud grandpapa and premier folk fiddler.

Him, he agrees to go to that Washington, D. C., and play his fiddle at a Smithsonian folk music festival, The crowds bother him some, but he enjoys the other musicians, and then the runaway horse comes, and he goes to get it. Takes the horse back, him, and finds a dead person.

I cannot reproduce Peter Bowen's well-written dialect, but I have talked to people, talk like this, and I know this kind of people. Good people. Good author.

You need to start with the first book in the series so that you know more about Du Pre' and the people who live in Montana ranch country. There are several other books in audio form as well, but you'll be hooked by the skills of Christopher Lane in "Coyote Wind," book one of the series. Then listen to this one. Big difference, this. Listen to the others that are already available, and wait anxiously for the rest of them, because even an average reader is better than no reader at all. (and yes, I did buy the kindle version of all of the books that did not come out in audio form until just this year).

Open your mind and dress warm, Montana pretty cold place most the time, but worth the trip. Take your dancin' boots and don't bump into them other people enjoying themselves.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

8 people found this helpful