A heart rending and thought provoking story

Beautifully written, with a narration that truly captures the characters. This book may make you laugh and may make you cry. it will definitely make you think.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Wow!

The plot is so beautifully thought out and intertwined. The narration had me hooked! I already miss the characters.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

This book made me think..

What is an evil inclination? When does it start? If the inclination begins with one's focus on a particular thing, will it effect changes on that person's behavior in other aspects of his/her life? I loved the interspersion of Talmud quotes. And the reader did an excellent job!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Couldn't stop listening!

I am not a religious person by any stretch of the imagination, so it’s always interesting to me when I listen to a story where the central characters are. In The Evil Inclination, Daniel Victor explores the meshing of two quite different religions of Judaism and Catholicism as told through the story of two young college-aged students falling in love in New York, and the trials and tribulations that follow.

Lev Levitski and his family are a devout Orthodox Jewish family. Lev tries to live his life by the Torah and the Talmud. His faith is put to the test when he spies Angela Pizatto in his economics class. She’s a stereotypical Italian American Catholic from New York, so the polar opposite of everything he tries to be. She’s loud, brash, and actually rather hard to like at first.

She comes across as a rather dreadful human being during their first date, so it all looks doomed, but of course being the main characters, you know it has to get better. What follows is a whirlwind romance coupled with a crisis of faith as they both dive headlong into the relationship. Angela as a character settles down quickly from the person we first met into someone who is genuinely interested in learning more about Lev and his traditions.

This was in part a romance and at the same time a lesson or brief introduction, to what it means to be someone of the Jewish faith. From Talmudic quotes to the intricate customs and traditions of Judaism they must follow that I’d never heard of before such as a prohibition on turning on lights during the sabbath to not dating outside of your religion.

While the latter is not exactly prohibited, the struggles the Lev has as he hides the relationship from everyone he knows as they wouldn’t understand was a bit of an eyeopener. He feels as if it’s a betrayal of everything he holds to be true while also accepting his love for Angela is also true.

Lev and Angela crisscross New York using the multitude of subway lines as they seek to keep their relationship secret. From gritty out-of-the-way diners to a tiny rundown apartment, they pursue their relationship. The writing is excellent, and I could picture these parts of the city most people never see without ever having visited.

Narration by Laura Patinkin was excellent and well-paced. She has a voice that’s easy to listen to, and the production was clean and error free.

This was an eye-opening and thoroughly enjoyable story of two people in love and an exploration of “the evil inclination” from Jewish theology. As I understand it from this book, the evil inclination refers to the human inclination toward things like selfishness, base desires, and moral failing. Not inherently “evil” in a purely negative sense but as part of the tension between self-interest and spiritual or ethical living.

Victor digs into this concept with Lev as his emotions and mind war with what he was brought up to believe and the life he finds himself presented with. So overall, a heartfelt exploration of faith, identity and love that I think will give me things to ponder on for a while.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Windows into 2 worlds

Insightful examination of two cultures. Interesting look at the meaning and effects of guilt. Wonderfully narrated.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Brought into another world so fabulously

When I started listening to the evil inclination, I thought this is a little slow and where is it going? But as soon as Lev met Angela, I couldn’t stop listening. Their love story develops with so many layers and such emotional love. I was constantly worried that they were going to be discovered. Each character is so interesting. I loved the grandmother.
The narration is wonderful and is so enjoyable to listen to. I learned so much and cannot forget the characters. I continue to think about them.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great narrator and enjoyable characters!

I loved Laura Patinkin’s narration! Her different voices for different characters were superb and her tone, flow and cadence perfect! The story was engaging and the characters entertaining. The ending was a nice surprise too.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great book

Just loved the story of Lev and Angela. Very thought provoking and it stayed with me long after I finished. Showed me a world I know very little about. The narration was great. I highly recommend.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Beautifully written, wonderful story

I so enjoyed listening to The Evil Inclination. The narrator’s telling of this charming and heartfelt story truly brought these most interesting and unpredictable characters to life. Couldnt recommend it more!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!