Credit where credit is due

I was interested in this book for a couple reasons. I recently read George Friedman's "America's Secret War" (which I loved) and wanted to see what Bergen thought about the way the Iraq war was sold to the American people. I also wanted to learn more about David Patraeus, the Anbar Awakening, and "the Surge". In general I found Bergen's account of the build-up to the Iraq war naive and missing the strategic and geopolitical reasons for the war that Friedman discusses. It was clearly bias and falls into the trap of believing that Bush is a fool, a trap that I fell into many times during his administration. I do give Bergen credit for his account of "the surge". He gives full credit to Bush for his willingness to keep in the fight and allowing Patraeus to pull victory from the jaws of defeat. And yes, it was victory that I never thought would be possible. More importantly, it demonstrated to the world that American resolve should not be underestimated. Obama gets it now and I bet that he has much more respect for Bush than he did before moving into the White House. Obama might even be a little embarrassed about some of his naive foreign policy remarks during the campaign.

Final thoughts: Bergen is a journalist with an above average understanding of the big picture when compared to his peers. But as we all know, that isn't much of compliment. The first half of the book betrays his agenda and his inability to grasp the strategic picture. The second half of the book saved it for me, especially the account of the surge. It gave me a new respect for Patraeus and his place in history.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

8 people found this helpful

very good, completes the picture - take a listen

Good listen, recommended. Very good narrator, material is in depth and well-put together. Have read/listened to a dozen books on the war, early Bin Laden, Irag, Afghanistan, Bush, etc. This covers a great deal of the same ground but is more complete and relevant with excellent new source material from those who participated in the process. I was part of the 5% of the USA population against the Iraq war when we went in, and dislike Bush and his administration intensely...but I must admit this book improved my view of Bush himself, while Condi Rice comes away as more damaged and Cheney and his cohorts remain evil. Also over time I become so consumed with how bad the Bush team was and how screwed up the war was it is a pleasant surprise to listen here to how well - proportionately - things are going now and how Bin Laden is back on his heels. The current group of military commanders also comes through in a positive light. Take a listen, this completes the picture, rounds out what you know and will give you hope.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

Blend of history and critique

Would you listen to The Longest War again? Why?

Listened to this after having read The Looming Tower. Taken together, they form bookends on the history of Al Qaeda with TLT tracing its history up to 9/11 and TLW from 9/11 to around 2009. Bergen is a respected terrorism analyst and this book is a mix of history and critique of US policy in combatting Al Qaeda. Bergen doesn't pull any punches here - by and large he asserts that US tactics and strategy in battling al Qaeda has mostly been characterized by missteps and failed opportunities. Still, this is an interesting read and examines the war on Islamic terrorism from both sides. It is a good read and never dull. Sometimes, though, I felt Bergen may have overstepped in the criticism department, not necessarily because what he says isn't true, but rather because it can jarringly interrupt the narrative. As well, the book was written before the killing of Osama bin Laden so the latter portion which speculates on his fate and the direction of the war seems outdated. Nonetheless, this is well worth reading and qualifies as a can't put down page turner.

What other book might you compare The Longest War to and why?

Read together with The Looming Tower by Lawrence Wright, the reader will get a comprehensive history of Al Qaeda.

What about Peter Ganim’s performance did you like?

Well read - never dry.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

From one who's been there

What did you love best about The Longest War?

As an Afghanistan combat veteran, I was interested to see what kind of view the author took on the conflict. From Iraq to Afghanistan and now Iraq again and Syria, the conflict in the middle east the the US has dubbed "The Global War On Terror" is so complicated and ever-evolving that you really need to understand it to understand the world. I'm happy to say that this book didn't take a left-wing "told you so" attitude toward the Bush administration; neither did it adopt the right-wing habit of defense of every move and decision the administration made. While it ends its descriptions of the conflict a couple years ago, when it was published, I think the intelligent reader can really take a lot from what it offers about the conflict to better understand the rise of ISIS and the current crisis in Syria and Iraq.

Have you listened to any of Peter Ganim’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

Outstanding narration.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Good one

Well narrated and a good story line. I would recommend this to my friends and family. Thanks to Audible for having this in store.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Excellent summary of the American war on terror

This book does an excellent job of walking through the war on terror since 9/11. For those who want to remember all the events and the sequence they played out in this is a good book. It's weakness, which has been mentioned by a couple of reviewers, is that it is not an intensive analysis of the events and players involved over that time. I don't think that was the intention of the book though. The author is a reporter who spent a lot of time in the regions and on the issues. He even had the chance to interview Bin Laden before 9/11. Definitely worth a read to remind yourself of the events that occurred over this last decade.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Somewhat Editorial but Informative

It is hard to believe, but the war in Afghanistan and Iraq is well over a decade long. I have followed the war since 9/11 and Peter Bergen in The Longest War fills in my rather US-centric point of view. Bergen knowledgably tracks the conflict(s) from the perspective of Al-Qaeda as well while weaving in history and cultural factors beneficial to the reader. He starts the book with events prior to 9/11 and brings us up to the recent past. The book does not cover the capture of Osama bin Laden, but does include a very interesting section about how he might have been captured. Comparing that analysis to what actually took place is informative. My reservation about this book is a matter of tone and style rather than substance. It reads as though it is a personal attack upon George Bush. I am not an apologist for the former President and he doesn’t need my help. However, there are several passages which are just annoying because of their editorializing approach. Other readers may not find this so nor as distracting. Finally, the book ends with “bin Laden is still out there and the war goes on” or some such. I really wanted Bergen to tell me what he believes this extended conflict means. One chapter could have pulled all of this together – at least from Bergen’s point of view. Otherwise, there are numerous insights which Bergen brings to the reader which are well worth the time. The reading of Peter Ganim is excellent

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Excellent

I have listened to this book twice from start to finish. Mr. Bergen does an excellent job of weaving the myriad stories, timelines, and perspectives together to create what I think is one of the best foundational books on the first ~8 years of America’s War on Terror. Some people may say that this books is biased towards the Bush administration, and maybe it is.

In spite of the potential bias which I think is negligible, Mr. Bergen is able to explain the Who, What, and Why behind events big and small that took place leading up to and following 9/11. Additionally, Peter Ganim was a great pick to read this book. His obvious familiarity with the Arabic language and his crisp monotone presentation I feel really enhanced the experience.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

The Longest Book

While this book was very informative and full of very interesting content, for me, it presents so many facts and dates etc that it would be much better appreciated in the written format and used for reference.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Solid overview of US War on Terror up to 2010

Solid overview of US War on Terror up to 2010. Is a little politically biased in parts, but generally tells a thorough story.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!