This episode is rated a 4 (on my Serious Crime Scale). On March 8, 2024, four buses filled with Delta Chi fraternity brothers from the University of Missouri arrived in Nashville, Tennessee, for a private event – the fraternity’s spring formal. Upon their arrival, the college students wasted no time hitting the streets of Nashville to visit the multitude of honkytonk bars on Broadway. But, unfortunately, their celebratory night ended in tragedy when one of the fraternity members, 22-year-old senior Riley Strain, went missing. Two weeks later, Riley’s body was found in the Cumberland River. Listen now to hear the full story.

Welcome to Part 2 of the UPDATED episode titled “Victim of a Narcissist.” In 2003, 20-year-old community college student Megan McDonald was brutally beaten and killed in a remote area of Orange County, New York. For over 20 years, the primary suspect in her murder was never publicly revealed – that is, until April 20, 2023, when the State Police announced they had finally made an arrest, and 42-year-old Edward Holley, an ex-boyfriend of Megan’s, was being charged with second-degree murder. But, y’all… there is SO much more to this story, so many twists and turns, which will explain why it took police over 20 years to bring charges to the man they adamantly believe is responsible for the crime. Listen now to hear the fully story.

This episode is rated a 5 (on my Serious Crime Scale). In March of 2003, 20-year-old community college student Megan McDonald was severely beaten and murdered, and then her lifeless body was dumped in a remote area. Like a real-life “Criminal Minds” story, the Behavioral Analysis Unit, or the BAU (a branch of the FBI), put together a profile of her killer. The BAU determined that Megan’s murderer was/is a person with textbook narcissistic personality disorder who couldn’t take no for answer.

Although they had a good idea of exactly who this person was for years, police never publicly identified Megan’s killer – that is, until April 20, 2023. And THIS is where our update comes in. When I first dropped this episode on April 10, 2023, it was just 10 days before police announced that Megan’s ex-boyfriend, a man by the name of Edward Holley, had been arrested for her murder. Now, when I first covered this story, all investigators were saying at the time was that they hoped to make an arrest soon… Y’all, I didn’t realize they meant like, TEN days away soon… So, that means when I ran the episode, I told the whole story without ever identifying a suspect. In fact, I used the pseudonym of John, instead of using the suspect’s real name because I didn’t know his real name at the time. So, NOW, I’d like to replay the episode. I’m not going to re-record it, but when you are listening to it this time around (or, perhaps the first time if you’re new here), I want you to do so with this guy in mind. Every time I refer to the prime suspect or the pseudonym of John, just know it is this guy, Edward Holley, who police were looking at the whole time.

But stick around until the end because not only will I give you additional information about Edward Holley, but as you’ve probably noticed already from the title of this episode, there is SO much more to this story and SO much more that needs to be told – so much so that I couldn’t fit it all into one single episode. I needed to make it a two-parter.