On this week’s Thumb War, we revisit the world of horny, doomed teens and ask the question: what if they were even dumber… and older?

Yes, it’s the legacy sequel to I Know What You Did Last Summer, and it’s back with the original cast, zero shame, and a whole lot of questionable decisions. We dive into why this movie exists, how it compares to Scream and Top Gun: Maverick, and whether legacy sequels are just nostalgia traps covered in blood (and denim).

Also:

Wicked looks incredible — even if the press tour made us want to eat glass

The Smashing Machine might break your heart and Dwayne Johnson Shaq is owed an 18-foot Superman crystal Christopher Nolan has fans buying IMAX tickets for movies that don’t even exist yet

...and yes, we’re still mad about the soup-slurping Aronofsky trailer.

Join Our Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/c/isthisgood

A Vegas recap, a very cursed headline, and a whole lotta ass talk. This one’s for the P-Hounds.

Join our Patreon to hear the FULL episode. https://www.patreon.com/c/isthisgood

Walking & Talking At NBA Summer League: https://youtu.be/2QbXHwVOAq4
The infamous “whisk” article: http://bit.ly/458MnGu

James Gunn has officially launched his DC Universe—and we’ve got thoughts. In this episode of ThumbWar, Rachel and J.D. dive headfirst into the chaotic brilliance of the new Superman movie, complete with our favorite needle-drops, Krypto chaos, Lex Luthor love, and Mr. Terrific stealing the whole damn show.

We’re breaking down:

• David Corenswet’s Superman vs. Henry Cavill’s legacy 🦸
• Rachel Brosnahan’s Lois Lane and THAT bubble scene 💥
• The MVPs: Krypto, Mr. Terrific, Guy Gardner, and more 🚀
• Gunn’s perfect blend of chaos, comedy, and comic book canon 🎬

This IS your dad’s Superman—and we’re here for it.

⭐️ Join our Patreon for ad-free episodes! Patreon.com/isthisgood

💥 SPOILERS AHEAD. 🎧 Subscribe for more unhinged pop culture showdowns.

#Superman #JamesGunn #DCU #MovieReview #ThumbWarPodcast