Why is His Girl Friday the movie not a good idea, but Guys & Dolls magnificently was? The answer is in the third of David and Paul’s Three Questions For What Makes A Musical: Does it sing? Do I care? And, Why This Show, Why Now? A little sneak preview conversation about the Gordon & Goldsmith opus My Improbable Sisters, streaming now on YouTube (starring Jenna Lea Rosen and Tony™ nominee Jasmine Amy Rogers). Some Legally Blonde, some Les Miz (an epic disagreement about the scansion of “On My Own,” some firsthand John Caird stories from Paul… why David and Paul are loving writing their next big project, an adaption of Dickens’ Little Dorrit… and then, per Paul’s request, this week’s Paul & David Break It Down concerns one of David’s patter songs (a waltz, and with a French accent) from that very work-in-progress. A peek into David’s lyric-writing process and the collaboration between David and Paul writ large. Not that you asked. Wait though, you did. Enjoy.

After refusing to divulge the details of Paul’s lunch the previous day with David’s wife, Paul starts us off with a throwback to Dylan and why greatness in one genre isn’t always a guarantor of success in Musical Theatre. Then Paul divulges his three Groundbreaking Musicals: A Chorus Line, Company and Hamilton. This leads to a mock trial of Groundbreaking v Inspirational, with David representing the defense. An overdue look at the great song “Omar Sharif” from the great The Band’s Visit follows, and backstage stories of how that song, along with some of our greatest moments from our own stuff on Broadway, faced the back alley dumpsters before being rescued. A little song, a little dance, a little “The Miller’s Son” (from the foundational A Little Night Music) down your pants. Then back to our main subject of the day, how to make pop music work on a stage… and what to do about all those 8 beats in between lines they inevitably, problematically, bring along with them. What am I supposed to do here, Maestro? Hence, this week’s title.

Paul and David start off this week’s nerdfest on a tangent about their favorite musical of this season, Maybe Happy Ending, some more reflections on A Little Night Music (natch), and reminiscences about Theatre Projections of Olde (We’re looking at you, H2$). Then Paul and David treat us to some first-hand stories of Paul’s Jane Eyre on Broadway and David’s Motown The Musical on Broadway…and then the drill-down begins on what happens to your brain on Hamilton, and why you may not have been able to have gotten it all the first time (you won’t want to miss David spitting that Jefferson lick—or maybe you will). Finally, staying on theme, this week’s Paul & Dave Break-It-Down looks in granular detail at the great rap, yes, rap lyric of Jason Robert Brown’s “Wind In My Sails” from, you guessed it, The Connector.