Episode 018 of That Was Disappointing is Live.

18!? We’re now legally adults! *insert fart sound*

Our first topic is what songs invoke nostalgia within us. You can color us all surprised that Art picked *NSYNC. It’s not like any of us remember his “Dawson Leary” phase, after all.

Our second topic is what things you can’t look away from. At least, we think that was Josh’s topic. He’s new to the show (and we already have another panelist named Josh), so let’s come him some slack... this time! Next time, Hell hath no fury like a purple nurple.

Our third topic is what changes you would like to make to your body. At least Nunu’s response was realistic; meanwhile, Producer Dave had to opt for a 14’ schlong. Only 13’ 11” to go. Hi yoooo!

Our final topic is celebrity freebies. If you’re in a serious relationship or married, you’ve had this conversation with your SO. Although the fact that Alex’s wife has a harem does give him pause...

Episode 019 of That Was Disappointing is Live.

Similarly, there are only 19 plagues left in the year. Eat, drink and be merry!

Our first topic is things that turned out waaaaaaaaaay more awkward from what you expected. How Chris thought a jar of peanut butter, a hungry Pomeranian, and her sheer machismo could’ve ended any other way is beyond the rest of us, but we applaud how forthcoming he was.

Our second topic is what’s your crazy, most irrational fear. Most of us have fond memories of Lex’s “Is this the Gehrig” phase. As an aside, his new fear is why Producer Dave was taking such vigorous notes while Chris described his trust in our first topic...

Our third topic is what you’d do if you knew it was your final day alive. Given the state of the world, our best guess is Art’s read the writing on the wall. Stay tuned for our Very Special Memorial Edition of That was Disappointing coming soon!

Our final topic is what movie didn’t get a sequel that should have. We didn’t have the heart to tell Ken that his pick of The Land Before Time was unwarranted. And why does Howard the Duck keep coming up in these film topics!

Episode 020 of That Was Disappointing is Live.

Only one episode until we’re of legal age to drink. Please don’t check our college records.

Our first topic is what would be the best (and conversely, worst) video game worlds to live in. I guess we should count ourselves lucky Art’s choice wasn’t The Guy Game. Seriously, Wiki (is that a verb?) it. Still, Animal Crossing gave us all pause.

Our second topic is what was your biggest disappointments from high school. Surprisingly, James’ wasn’t that he was locked in the locker every other day. Now, how Producer Dave was the one shoving kids into lockers everyday is anyone’s guess.

Our third topic is tattoos. If forced to get one, what would be your first (or next) tattoo? Lex’s choice of Gadget (from Chip ‘n Dale: Rescue Rangers fame) on his derrière was... yeah.

Our final topic is what were the Drug PSA’s that scarred you growing up. From diving into empty swimming pools to... well, we kinda ran out of ideas there. But hey, fun topic regardless. Take a bow, Ben!