Excellent to start an honest and open conversation

Amazing, enthralling, heartfelt are some of the words that come to my mind when stating my opinion about this podcast, I'm a HP fan I fell in love with the books and I can say that so far I've been able to find all of the elements that JK Rowlings describes about them and as an adult I've come to understand the beauty of grey that is human nature. I can't wait to listen more about these conversations. I can't tell you with words how important it is for our society (in the light of the polarization of the speech that currently permeates our society) to be able to listen to a person who was always an ally and now is being vilified for stating controversial and sometimes hurtful opinions silenced without any chance of explaining herself, I can see her humanity and I understand where her heart its on those issues, I myself share some of her worries, I considered myself a trans ally, I believe in their rights and the acknowledgement of their human experience and I'm a feminist too, so I believe that a deep conversation is due, I believe that we as adults should be capable of having difficult conversations, ghosting each other and silencing dissident voices can only get us so far, I believe everything can be done with respect, love and understanding, and those 2 eps are full of that.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

A great podcast, very balanced presentation

I really enjoyed this podcast. It presented the information in a clear and balanced way. It allowed each side to express their views and to respond to criticism. I believe what J.K Rowling said was taken out of context and she offered a very clear explanation of the very specific issues she sees a problem with. This was a very intelligent conversation between intelligent people and presented in a wonderful podcast. Thank you to all involved!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

I’ve been waiting for this

I’ve been waiting to see Rowling’s side and she didn’t disappoint. Really well done and thoughtful.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

loved it

Great point of view from both sides of opinion on the books and the Author. I haven't read the books but 2 episodes in I'm enjoying learning about Joanne Rowlings and her thoughts on the characters. Very well done.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Fasanating and enthralling

I started yesterday and could not stop listening. Very well done, I look forward to more.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Refreshing

Thoughtful approach to one of the biggest issues of the decade. Even if you think you know where it’s going- you don’t.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Perspective

When forming an opinion on something, it's good and helpful to have the entire story. Too often we listen to our chosen sources and make our story based solely on, perhaps, biased information. I loved the rounded roundedness this podcast took. We need to continuously counter ourselves and look for why the "other side" of an issue hold validity for those individuals. We are all living life based off our own experiences, and while experiences can't be denied, we have to be aware that they shape us all into the people we are today. Good and evil does not exist in the majority of issues we argue. There are fundamentals where the majority of people are going to agree, and for the items where we see differences, it would help us progress to continuously ask "why". Why does this person think this way? Rather that then believing them to simply be evil. That's too easy and ultimately dehumanizing and disconnecting. we should look for ways to connect instead of focusing on that which disconnects us.
Excellent podcast. In my opinion, it was clearly thought out and executed very well. Everyone with questions about this issue, as well as those who seek to see more value in asking questions, should listen to this.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Misplaced anger and selective outrage

I really enjoyed the podcast. It pretty much said what I thought it would. JK Rowling made statements that are easy to see as bigoted, however, I doubt she has any real issues with the trans community. Rowling 's main issue seems to stem from her past traumas. She seems more concerned with the possibility of unscrupulous men pretending to be trans in order to harm women. Unfortunately all of the hate she has received from the trans community and some of their allies are confirming some of her misconceptions. Because if we're honest, how can you sling highly sexually violent slurs at women and consider yourself a woman? Using slurs rooted in misogyny and patriarchy run counter to gaining allies and support....
You can't simultaneously stand on the shoulders of feminism while kicking feminists in the head. People don't like discussion because they are uncomfortable with actual discourse. A few clicks from the safety of your keyboard and everyone thinks they're a warrior.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Thoughtful & thought provoking, unfailingly fair

Megan Phelps-Roper is uniquely qualified to host this conversation. She takes the responsibility seriously, and treats all with respect & fairness. So good I’ve listened three times!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

TERF

I understand where Joe is coming from. Trans women are not biologically female. no amount of drugs, surgery, or wishful thinking will make it so. Trans woman chose an alternative lifestyle, which is their right. for thousands of years women have been subjugated and abused just for being born our gender. We have had to fight hard to be treated as human beings. We didn't chose this life. So don't give us shit for wanting to protect our legacy. Go on living your beautiful life and leave us to do the same.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!