Thumb War Podcast By Bleav Rachel Selig & Jason Doyle cover art

Thumb War

Thumb War

By: Bleav Rachel Selig & Jason Doyle
Listen for free

Thumb War is your weekly showdown over movies, streaming series, and pop culture mayhem. Rachel and JD dive into what’s worth watching (and what deserves jail time), dishing out unfiltered recaps, reviews, and cinematic chaos. Smart-ish, savage-ish, and spoiler-heavy.Matthew Osten Social Sciences
Episodes
  • Fantastic Four: First Steps Review | Jeshua Kidd on Marvel’s Most Family-Driven Movie Yet
    Jul 28 2025

    Fantastic Four: First Steps isn’t just another superhero reboot — it’s about family.

    This week on Thumb War, JD is joined by very special guest Jeshua Kidd (No Dunks, The Athletic) to break down Marvel’s latest MCU installment — a retro, cosmic, heartstring-tugging space race where Reed Richards might as well be Dom Toretto with a PhD.

    Subscribe to our Patreon for AD-FREE Episodes: http://bit.ly/44Mo8xU

    We talk:

    Pedro Pascal as Reed Richards (our stretchy dad) Vanessa Kirby’s Sue Storm Julia Garner as a Silver Surfer with real menace Baby Franklin and the most awkward press conference of all time Galactus, teleporting planets, and how science is the new nitrous

    Plus: Reactions to Avatar: Fire & Ash, Tron Ares, Predator: Badlands and Caught Stealing Jared Leto discourse, again What happened to John Malkovich and the super apes subplot?

    Spoilers from the jump. Because, in the words of Dominic Toretto… it's all about family.

    Leave us a five-star review wherever you get your pods Email: thumbwarpod@gmail.com

    Show more Show less
    1 hr and 41 mins
  • Take Me To The River | PATREON PREVIEW
    Jul 24 2025

    We kick off with a haunted waitress and end up baptizing strangers in lakes — which honestly says a lot about this episode. Jason may or may not have been covertly baptized by a rogue Catholic. Rachel wears a wet t-shirt (kind of). Plus: Emmy nomination chatter, ghost gossip, and a passionate defense of Slow Horses. This one’s got spirits — both supernatural and awards-season related.

    ⭐️ Subscribe to our Patreon to hear the FULL EPISODE: http://bit.ly/44Mo8xU

    Show more Show less
    2 mins
  • A Bunch Of Dummies Get What’s Coming to Them | Thumb War Ep. 3
    Jul 21 2025

    On this week’s Thumb War, we revisit the world of horny, doomed teens and ask the question: what if they were even dumber… and older?

    Yes, it’s the legacy sequel to I Know What You Did Last Summer, and it’s back with the original cast, zero shame, and a whole lot of questionable decisions. We dive into why this movie exists, how it compares to Scream and Top Gun: Maverick, and whether legacy sequels are just nostalgia traps covered in blood (and denim).

    Also:

    Wicked looks incredible — even if the press tour made us want to eat glass

    The Smashing Machine might break your heart and Dwayne Johnson Shaq is owed an 18-foot Superman crystal Christopher Nolan has fans buying IMAX tickets for movies that don’t even exist yet

    ...and yes, we’re still mad about the soup-slurping Aronofsky trailer.

    Join Our Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/c/isthisgood

    Show more Show less
    2 hrs and 1 min
No reviews yet