A masterpiece

Great book. Halve an has really outdone himself. Can't wait to read the rest of the trilogy!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Excellent story AND narration

If you could sum up Marsbound in three words, what would they be?

I love Joe Haldeman. The Forever War is one of my favorite sci-fi books ever. I listened to Starbound first, not realizing it was part of a trilogy. After finishing it, I HAD to start at the beginning of the trilogy,so got Marsbound. It is another excellent Haldeman story!

What does Liza Kaplan bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

She does a really great job of bringing Carmen to life. She sounds just the way I figured she'd sound at the age she is in this book.

Any additional comments?

Get the entire trilogy. It's an excellent read!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

NOT FOR CHILDREN

this audiobook start out with a child announcing "audible kids".the story contains sex, profanity, alcohol and drugs. marsbound is a light space opera, quite enjoyable (if you like the genre),but not for the easily offended or children. obviously classified by someone who only read the synopsis.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

Bound for Listening

I have previously enjoyed Haldeman's Forever Peace audio book, and recommend that one as well. There is the perfect mix of science, plot, and character to blend a really good listen.
I was a little leery about purchasing this one on account, that the narrator of the story is a young woman. However Haldeman pulled it off well. And I was able to suspend my usual penchant for macho characters, to relate to her story.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Weak performance

Sorry, but it was impossible to get into this story because of the poor performance. Her diction is excellent, her voice is pleasant, but she gives no life to the characters and I felt like I was listening to a second-grade teacher read to children. I lasted abut 45 minutes, then gave up.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Weak and slow moving story

What could have made this a 4 or 5-star listening experience for you?

It needed to be faster paced with real conflict. Everybody were too accomodating of each other. There was very little suspense. Most of the dialog was on the level of gossip. This just wasn't in the same class as the

Would you ever listen to anything by Joe Haldeman again?

Forever War is one of the best Sci Fi books out there.

Did the narration match the pace of the story?

The narrator did an OK job. Her performance matched the charactor.

You didn’t love this book... but did it have any redeeming qualities?

There were no moments in the book I can offer as particularly interesting.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Meh.

"Marsbound" initially impressed me as a better than average YA sci-fi story; Carmen seemed at first an interesting character to get to know, and the structure of the story recalled many of the Heinlein YA stories that I cut my teeth on, many years ago. Around the time that Carmen was getting acclimated to Mars and Solingen kept getting nastier, I started to chafe at the lack of pace and coherence. I eventually persevered to the end, but by the time I finished it was more of a chore than a pleasure.

Perhaps had I read this book instead of listening to it, I'd have enjoyed it more. Kaplan's narration was just bad. I know I've been spoiled by narrators such as John Lee and the late, lamented Patrick Tull, but I had expected someone who is, after all, a voice actress to do a better job. Her "voice" for Carmen and the overall narration sounded like a child in elementary school reading a book in a sing-song (truly jarring when she was narrating a sex scene) and her voices for other females reminded me more of some anime characters I've heard. Really, really bad anime characters.

I don't recommend this book. For good YA titles, try John Marsden's "Tomorrow" series, or the YA books by Charles de Lint. For good YA sci-fi, Heinlein is dated, but still good. John Scalzi's "Zoe's Tale" is great. Take the money you would have spent on this book, and look for one of those instead.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Maybe if I was young and female?

I generally like Haldeman but this book did nothing for me. The science was weak and the perspective was from a teen girl concerned with what makeup to take to Mars. Perhaps if I were preteen and female I would find something in this book, but I don't see it at all. There is zero action and nothing thought provoking, funny, scary, or exciting. I really don't understand what the author was attempting. Either I totally missed it or the author failed utterly. Either way I will not finish this series.

The narration was clear and understandable, but could not really help the material.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Poor Narration, Awkward Sex Scenes

I'm only halfway in and it's just not grabbing me, but the reason I felt it needed a review is that the narration is pretty mediocre and the sex scenes just strike an odd tone. The narrator is just "ok" for the main character and truly awful for most side characters; making them sound like the badly voiced Simpsons characters. What struck me as off about the story, besides its overall lackluster pace, is that the sex scenes are written about a barely adult teenage female romanced by a 30 something pilot, all of which is written in way more explicit detail than I needed to hear from a 65 year old male writer. So far, scenes that could've been left at brief overviews and still delivered the needed plot points have been broken out in strangely detailed terms describing positions and specific sexual acts taking place that just come across as weirdly unnecessary detail. All in all, I will finish it and hope for the best, but its not impressing me at the halfway point.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Joe Haldeman, where have you gone?

I've read Haldeman avidly for years, and his early stuff (the "Forever War," the "Worlds" trilogy, "Tools of the Trade," etc) stand the test of time.? The last several years, though, I 've picked up each of his books with dread (but hope -- that's what makes me pick them up in the first place).? With the possible exception of "Camouflage," which wasn't bad, my dread has been confirmed.This was not a good book. It was pretty bad.? To be fair, though, I have to admit that it's the first of his books that I've listened to, and the reader was comparably poor ... maddenly poor.? I made it through the whole thing only because it's Haldeman -- I love this man's early writing so much that I'm willing to take the chance every time a new title comes out.? Sadly, I'll probably do that until one of us kicks the bucket -- that's how good those early books were.? Now, if he comes out with something even close to what he has demonstrated he is capable of, all will be forgiven.? I'll put up with a lot of not-good books for another that I'll enjoy more than once.Sadly, this book is not it.? This book is as far from it as a book can be.? If you want to experience the writer Joe Haldeman can be, pick up something he wrote in the 70s or 80s.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful