Thoughtful 1st contact scifi w communication focus

This beautiful, moving book strongly reminded me of the years I lived abroad and my time as an English as a Second Language teacher. It’s about communication – the difficulty of understanding another being – whether you are from the same neighborhood or completely different planets. Yes, there’s a lot about faith and God, but you do not have to be a deeply religious person to get a lot out of this novel. In scifi terms, it’s not an action-based plot, so those expecting a thrill-a-minute will be disappointed. But if you like your thoughtful first-contact scifi with a bit of linguistics added in, you will get a lot out of this novel.

[I listened to this as an audio book performed by Josh Cohen. I thought he did a great job with the alien language, but I did speed up the audio to 1.25 because he read a bit slowly for my taste.]

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Mixed emotions

This book was slow at times, and hard to follow at others, but it really sucked you in. I didn’t like the ambiguity of the ending, and wish we knew what happened to Peter, Bea, Oasis, and Earth.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Science fiction with sensibilities of Literary Fic

The story is simple, Peter, pastor with a history of drug abuse and alcoholism prior to becoming a Christian is hired to go to the planet Oasis to minister to the aliens there. A lot has been made of this being a genre defying novel, but I did not think that it was widely outside of either Literary Fiction or Science Fiction and fans of both should consider it part of the genre they prefer most.

The main story of the book is really about the marriage of Peter on Oasis and his wife, Bea, back in England. They can communicate, but only via email like plain text. And then, only when he is at the main human complex and not when he is living with the aliens. The physical distance matters. But the experiential difference matters more. For Peter, he is absorbed in his work and the transition from the alien settlement to the human settlement is always a cultural shock. Add to that the increasing desperation of Bea, and Peter emotionally hides.

The book drags a little bit in the middle. The cultural learning that Peter needs to do learn about the aliens, and about the humans that are willing to go to an alien world, matters to the story, but there is a lot of explanation and internal dialogue. This is primarily an internal book. There are a few segments of action, but the main story is about people and culture and marriage and faith. I generally like internal books and I certainly like this one. But there is a bit of drag to the middle and the end will not please many.

The author is not a Christian, but gets so much right about Christianity in the book. World Magazine named it their fiction book of the year in 2015. I saw one person compared The Book of Strange New Things to The Poisonwood Bible, which other than the fact they are both about missionaries seems like an odd comparison. Both the missionary characters want to share their faith, but there is a real difference in method. Peter truly loves the aliens, while the father in Poisonwood Bible seems oblivious to the humanness of the Africans that he is ministering to. In both books there is an all consuming focus which leaves the needs of the families far behind the needs of the work.

In the end I think the exploration of ideas about marriage and distance and the exploration of faith and calling makes this well worth reading, even it is a little long and meandering at times. The audiobook was very well done.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Very good

Like many great stories, it engages you and then frustratingly leaves you wanting to engage more with the characters even at the end. Well done.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

good story but some voices are just too much to ta

struggled to finish. intriguing story but the narrated voices of the aliens was just too hard to listen to

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Excellent portrayal of a Christian in space

This was a really good story that kept me interested to the end. The standout aspect of the book was the excellent portrayal of a Christian minister in a difficult situation.

Unlike other books about space-going evangelists that I've seen, there is no parody or mockery of faith or Christianity here. The portrayal of the Christian minister protagonist rings true and spot-on. It was so good that at first I suspected that the author was a Christian himself, and this was a "Christian book" in disguise, but that's definitely not the case.

My main complaint about the book is that it doesn't deliver on all of the interesting threads that are started throughout the story. I felt that this was a big problem for the book. Even though it was a fun listen, the ending left me very disappointed.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

As Odd and Dispiriting as it is Capitvating

If you could sum up The Book of Strange New Things in three words, what would they be?

Lonely, cosmic heartbreak.

What did you like best about this story?

The fantastical elements of the book either creep up on you so slow or are thrust upon you so fast that you're as genuinely jarred as the main character upon realizing that the world you're visiting is unlike anything you'd expected or experienced. This happens because of how believable and grounded so much of the story is in the things we understand and can relate to - loneliness, crisis of faith, determination of will and the inability to communicate with a far away loved one, among others.

What does Josh Cohen bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

I wouldn't necessarily say that Faber's story doesn't stand well enough on simply the merits of his words, because he's crafted something that's at once both thrillingly alien and resonantly human at the core. But having experienced his novel through Josh Cohen's mammoth range of raw, realized characterizations, I couldn't possibly fathom the story divorced of him.

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

The third-to-last and second-to-last chapters - in the infirmary with Jesus Lover 5 and in Peter's Church with him speaking in all Oassan - are both equally crushing.

Any additional comments?

On top of his skillful handling of international accents that are individually crafted for every single character so that you know that person intimately the moment they appear and reappear in the story, Cohen's unique and jaw-dropping representation of the Oassans' gargling, guttural dialect is something masterful to behold.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

9 people found this helpful

Ugh

There better be a sequel! It's like he came up with a story but couldn't figure out how to end it. Just lots of unanswered questions.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Ending!

Hated the ending! loved the journey. It left me wanting to know more. Maybe a sequel is in the works. I have nothing more to say!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

OMG

Absolute, arduous torture. I've listen to most of Mr Faber's books and knew going forward that this one might be as annoying as the last, but I'm an optimist.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!