Wonderful 4th part of the story of Nathaniel Bumppo!

The narrator is a New Englander so it made it more authentic to me. The picture painted of the “progress” and settling of our nation was quite moving from several points of view. I feel sad that the fields around me have been supplanted with houses. I can’t imagine the sadness of watching all the trees cut down to begin settling a place as that to which Natty Bumppo was witness.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Old fashioned but still relevant, edition is poor

I'm listening through all the leather-stocking tales, which are not only good stories, but little time capsule glancing back to a vanished American culture. Cooper's sensibilities are surprisingly modern, more modern in some ways than Samuel Clemens', who was born later, but raised in a southern (border) state.

This book is especially interesting because it gives a sympathetic but contemporary glimpse at the conflict between American 'Pioneers' and the indigenous people and genuine frontiersmen whose land they settled. These books are in some ways the first 'western' novels, but they do not have any of the simple-minded racism of the movie westerns Hollywood churned out in the 1950s. In the context of our time, the book will be considered racist, of course. Taken in the context of its own time, the book is progressive.

Though it takes place after 'the last of the Mohicans' this was published earlier. But it is more politically relevant today than that more famous work. The Pioneers was published seven years before the ethnic cleansing of Jackson's genocidal "Trail of Tears," and it reminds us that, even 190 years ago, the 'nativist' and 'manifest destiny' movements were objected to by many Americans (Cooper's books were popular at the time). The book is also a poignant warning and reminder that the difference between right and wrong can be over-ridden by corrupt interest combined with jingoism.

It also seems to me that Oliver Wendell Holmes 'Breakfast Table' books, written 30+ years later, owe something to the first few chapters of this novel. At any rate, the conversations among the 'Pioneers' seem authentic, and to have the same 'culture of conversation' that existed then, but has died away now. A time when Americans could disagree without name calling - definitely worth remembering.

Killavey has a clear voice and his words are always easy to catch and understand. His female falsetto is problematic, but that's not unusual in a male reader. But his pronunciation is more problematic (I blame this on the editor, more than the narrator). I'm guessing he is from the UK, based on the way he pronounced 'slough' (to rhyme with bough, rather than through - the way an American would pronounce it, and the way the characters in the book would have pronounced it). But why a Brit would be brought in to read Fenimore Cooper is beyond my guess. And how a Brit could think that the interjection 'och' (which is Scottish, after all) should be pronounced to rhyme with 'botch' is a mystery (and an annoyance) to me. These are just two examples of many mistakes. Any American listener will catch several more errors.

The editing is problematic in other ways, too. The transitions between chapters is non-existent. Between the last word of one chapter, the statement of the title of the next chapter, and the first word of the next chapter, there is no time-space at all. The chapter titles were clearly added afterwards, but they were added badly. Indeed, the last words of at least one chapter were simply chopped off. I suspect Mr. Killavey's voice, probably more sonorous in real life, was 'sped up' by the editors, too.

In sum, I heartily recommend the book, but not this audio edition.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Painfully bad reading of a 1790's country tale

An interesting account of social rituals and the invasions of government into rural life in the 1790's, nearly ruined by the worst reader who has ever massacred a book. Does he pause after every four words hallucinating nonexistent commas, or is he short-winded? Does he accent the wrong words in every sentence because he is reading the text for the first time? The mispronounciations are the least of his sins. This would be a charming comedy of up-country manners, frontier politics, and Revolution-era diction, but the tour is made painful by the halting, spavined nag we are forced to ride. The book is worth the time if you're interested in American history or the old age of Natty and Chingatchcook - but find a version read by anybody else.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

Very good not as good as Deerslayer

Where does The Pioneers rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?

Medium it is not as good as the previous books

Would you be willing to try another book from James Fenimore Cooper? Why or why not?

Yes

Have you listened to any of Jim Killavey’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

Yes very good

If you were to make a film of this book, what would be the tag line be?

After the wilderness

Any additional comments?

Good book finishes his other stories that were great.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

A glimpse of the past

I found it fascinating to read historical fiction from someone who lived close to those times. There's a colorful cast of well-drawn characters, and though it didn't have a lot of action until the last third of the story, it was informative and thought-provoking. The wonderful ending made me so glad I stayed with it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

time for a remake

The narrator is killing me. He enunciates well but he is just reading in a singsong manner with no sense that he's paying attention to what he's saying. I don't think I can make it through because of his voice. I've read the book before so it's not the writing style that is offputting. It's the poor reading style.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Excellent and Insightful

This book has has many strange twists and turns and is both historical, in the broad sense of historical fiction, and an adventure story. It is written, as were most books back then in a rather rambling and wordy style. This was, after all, way before radio and TV and people liked their entertainment to last. Some readers of today, however, may not have the patience for a work like this. I like to do a little research on the classics I get and found an encyclopedia article that said the book "may be considered one of the first ecological novels in the United States." ( from Wikipedia.org ) That statement intrigued me but turned out to be quite true. There are many discussions in it about conservation and the use of natural resources. Amazing insight
for its time! The narrator was pretty good but made what I thought were a few pronunciation errors. However I checked them out and they were ok - alternatives pronunciations in a couple of cases, but acceptable.
Five Stars

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

17 people found this helpful

Great Story...Performance was not so Great

You really have listen carefully to this version of the Pioneers. The production seems to have the performance set one notch below Alvin and Chipmunks. It what seems a race to the finish, the performance seems to not take a breath!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Poor recording

I very much enjoyed the novel. I was very irritated by the lack of any space between the chapters. Often the new chapter would cut off the last part of the final sentence from the previous chapter. Other than that, I enjoyed part 4 in the Leatherstocking series.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Terrible reader.

Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?

One of the worst readers I have heard on audible. Monotone with a stilted and unnatural rhythm. He does not pay any attention to punctuation and instead pauses at a cadence that according to a syllable count. It is like he is trudging through the paragraphs like a soldier on a long march.

It is awful and makes it difficult to follow. "Unbearable" and "tedious" are the best words to describe it.

Would you be willing to try another one of Jim Killavey’s performances?

Absolutely not. I wish there was a feature to "hide" all books read by this author. Never again. I am forturnate it was a low cost book. But given how terrible the reader is I am not surprised the book goes for a pittance.

Any additional comments?

Implement a "hide" feature according to readers. This way we can avoid mistakenly buying books from terrible readers more than once.

It could also be a valuable metric audible could use in cooperation with publishers to eliminate terrible readers.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!