High adventure and law breaking in the Skies!

UPDRAFT was a definite winner for me. From the characters to the mysterious world set high in the air amidst bone towers it wasn't surprising that I was hooked from the start. The story stars a young female protagonist named Kirit who is a law/rule breaker. These law breaks she commits seem to be done in ways she thinks would be harmless but ultimately end up costing her and her family almost everything. The progression of her character was well executed and each choice she makes has a major impact on the direction both her life and the story takes.

Character Driven

The was a very character driven novel. The world is fascinating but instead of laying on a huge amount of worldbuilding information the major focus is on Kirit and everything she does/is going through. We do ultimately see how her life and actions fit into the bigger picture of what has been going on in the past generation of people within the Spire, the Towers and all of it's people. This is a story of secrets upon secrets and Kirit is determined to uncover as many as she can. She wants to know everything but she also wants to do what she thinks is the right thing for everyone. It was a winning point for her personality that she was willing to make sacrifices at times and not just be selfish. I thought at the beginning that she was going to be a very selfish character but that was so far from the truth. She might make what some would consider missteps along the way but I think all of them work perfectly and I can't imagine making different decisions myself.

Family, Flying and who comes First

There is a big focus on family in this book. The ones most important to you of course are your family but I was surprised to find people were not called by "mother" or "father" or "aunt" etc. - they were all called by their actual names. I really liked the way this was done as it made the family connection way less personal and made you really pay attention to how the characters acted versus relying on readers presumptions or implied affections that normally come with those terms. People really keep themselves a part from each other. Each tower looks after their own and isn't supposed to come to the defense of others. Also folks are really quick to turn their backs on people they deem unlucky. Its sad but all of that is explained in its own way as you move through the book. It made for a unique culture.

I know this is a weird way to combo it but this is a book of flying. Did you ever dream of flying? I think everyone does. I've never thought about hang gliding (the image pictured on the cover) but this really makes me want to try it. Honestly, I don't think the cover even accurately depicts the way I think the wings look based on the visuals that were painted in my mind from descriptions I picture them as actual maneuverable wings not a big clunky frame like a hang glider would have. The amazing descriptions given of the flying here really gave it a unique feel.

Great Supporting characters

While the focus and perspective is from that of Kirit the secondary characters were still well developed. I could have used a little more connection with her cousin Nat but the time spent with Wick and

On the World Building

While I loved the world I found myself constantly asking questions that I wish were answered. If the spires they inhabit are bone and is alive then just what is the creature that its growing from beneath the clouds? Are we ever going to learn what is beneath the clouds? How is it or what caused them to live on these spires. Much of this is probably ancient history for the characters in this world and thus no one likely knows I bet - so then that makes me wonder - am I ever going to learn these things? Because hey I really want to know. Thus things like that I'm still left wondering and hoping I'll get to know more in the future books. Which of course I most definitely will be reading because I found the world fascinating. I ultimately didn't mind that there were a number of unanswered world building/history type questions because if all of them were answered it might have tipped the scales the other way into the dreaded info dumping style and we all know how much that can hurt a book. I mention all of this because the world building style does leave a lot in question and this can either totally work for it with a reader or against it. For me I was given that perfect amount to get my brain whirring and leave me wanting more more more - in the best kind of way.

Thoughts on the Narration

Khristine Hvam does a wonderful job on the voice acting of Kirit. I loved the way her personality shone through in her voice. The atmosphere she was able to weave made me feel like I was right there next to Kirit soaring through the air or in the gyre with her. I must note that a few of the male voices (her cousin and Wick) didn't really sound distinctly different from each other to me but they still worked well. (Probably because each of the characters come heavily into play during mostly separate parts of the book.) There is singing in this book! So of course the narrator sings these parts. Be prepared - Kirit is known for how bad her signing is...so the narrator in turn gives us a very true to form performance. It didn't bother me but I can't help but note it because I found it funny that Khristine had to purposefully sing bad (not that I know what her real singing voice sounds like.) Overall, I highly recommend the audio edition whether you're an audio reader or not, and you know I will absolutely be reading the next book. More please now!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

24 people found this helpful

Slow start decent end

The story was very slow to start, but character building is like that. The overall story was good. Some parts were predictable, but other parts leave wondering about the origin of the characters and their society. I'll listen to the next book hoping it provides more.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Setting = Interesting and fun. Plot = So-so.

Every now and then it's fun to try something randomly new that tries things with an older formula. The young adult action formula usually involves a young person just entering adulthood, fighting back against a society full of morally corrupt adults trying to rule over them in some fashion (see "Hunger Games", "Maze Runner", "Red Rising", etc.).  "Updraft" is no different and goes through this formula like a check list.

Unfortunately, as a result, the story itself was only so so. The main character, Kirit, was likeable but lacked any traits that would make her very memorable. She spends most of her time trying to survive in a cutthroat society bound together by traditions that seem dubious at best. Nothing new here.

 On the plus side, the author imagined this plot to take place in one of the most wonderfully bizarre dreamlike setting thought up in a long time. Plot aside, it was the world "Updraft" takes place in that holds the most interest.

"Updraft" takes place in a world where a city of singing people live in bone towers growing into the sky from below cloudcover. They use handcrafted wings to travel around, are frequently attacked then eaten by floating near invisable squid like monsters called Skymouths, and a ruled over by a secretive society who have superpowered voices.

Different enough for you? Hey, "Updraft" asks for a lot of suspension of disbelief, but it gets the curious to hit the play button.

GENRE: Fantasy adventure.
AUDIENCE: Young Adult
SERIES: Bone Universe

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Predictable...but it is for teens or pre-teens...

Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?

I listened to it all but could walk away and leave it playing not missing anything. It should be labeled for young adults or even pre-teens.

Would you recommend Updraft to your friends? Why or why not?

Only to the young.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Loved every aspect of it

Easy to be captivated by story and reading! Hoping the sequals are read by the same person. Would definately enjoy listening to again.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Enjoyable for YA

I imagine this as a good read or listen for YA readers or enthusiasts. I felt was a bit slow and the narration overwrought at times so I personally did a lot of stop/starts to get through it all. Enjoyed the characters and overall story.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Steampunk Styled City

This one was a lot of fun. The narration was great, and the story was imaginative. The setting seemed rather steampunk - living "bone" cities and a culture based on flying. The main character has strong family ties and a passion for flying. (Flying is the main mode of transportation, and the basis of most trades.) This was a well written world, and definitely has a lot of political drama - sometimes a bit hard to listen to, since it's not a overly fair society. But the story is well told - and I highly recommend it!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

11 people found this helpful

Original story with great writing!

A wonderful departure from novels in this genre, Fran Wilde takes you into a world different from any I've seen prior to 'Updraft'.
Compelling characters, excellent prose, and a terrific story!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Started off well and then lost steam

The narrator was okay, she did a decent job bringing the first person POV to life. The world with towers of bone where the citizens of the city fly on silken wings was an interesting prospect, but I quickly tired of the protagonist. I don’t think I’ll be continuing the series.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Short of its potential

Would you try another book from Fran Wilde and/or Khristine Hvam?

No. Although decently written, the timeline and world are not fleshed out. Although the lead character has complex relationships with the other characters, the world around her is short on detail, and by the end of the book seems smaller, literally.
The basic premise that people live above clouds on towers and fly to get from one place to another should present an challenge for food supply, water, and many other cultural, social, political, etc. aspects of life. None of this addressed properly.
And while the story unfolds, and there are some vague hints at what might possibly be the evolution of this society, it is oddly isolated. There is one city, and nobody mentions other cities or curiosity about other cities or the wider world.
It seems like the story that the lead character goes through is generic enough that we can relate, and what made me interested is the odd surrounding world, and yet that was disappointingly vague and lacking detail and context that many of the major characters would have been aware of.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

17 people found this helpful