What If? Volume 2 Audiobook By Caleb Carr, Lance Morrow, Cecelia Holland, more cover art

What If? Volume 2

Eminent Historians Imagine What Might Have Been

 Preview
LIMITED TIME OFFER

3 months free
Try for $0.00
Offer ends July 31, 2025 at 11:59PM PT.
Pick 1 audiobook a month from our unmatched collection.
Listen all you want to thousands of included audiobooks, Originals, and podcasts.
Access exclusive sales and deals.
Premium Plus auto-renews for $14.95/mo after 3 months. Cancel anytime.

What If? Volume 2

By: Caleb Carr, Lance Morrow, Cecelia Holland, more
Narrated by: Murphy Guyer
Try for $0.00

$0.00/mo. after 3 months. Offer ends July 31, 2025 at 11:59PM PT. Cancel anytime.

Buy for $19.95

Buy for $19.95

Confirm purchase
Pay using card ending in
Switch payment method
By confirming your purchase, you agree to Audible's Conditions of Use, License, and Amazon's Privacy Notice. Taxes where applicable.
Cancel
There is no surer way to make history come alive than to contemplate those moments when the world's future - the government and wealth of nations, the faith and culture of generations - hung in the balance. In this volume, many of our brightest historians speculate about some of history's intriguing crossroads and the ways in which our lives may have been changed for the better - or the worse.

These original essays range across the full span of history. Geoffrey Parker describes ramifications that might have included a divided Reformation movement, a strengthened Catholic leadership, and no European settlements in the Americas. And Caleb Carr argues that we could have been spared the horrific last six months of World War II in Europe if Eisenhower had seized his chance to destroy the Nazis in the fall of 1944.

This all-star list of award-winning and best-selling authors includes Lance Morrow, Andrew Roberts, Cecilia Holland, Theodore F. Cook, and Geoffrey C. Ward, and is edited by Robert Cowley.

©2001 American Historical Publications, Alll Rights Reserved (P)2001 Simon & Schuster Inc., AUDIOWORKS Is an Imprint of Simon & Schuster Audio Division, Simon & Schuster Inc. Americas Military Political Science Politics & Government Social Sciences United States World Interwar Period Imperialism Self-Determination Middle Ages Soviet Union Socialism War Refugee Russia Winston Churchill Imperial Japan Africa Middle East Social justice Roosevelt Family Franklin D. Roosevelt Latin America Capitalism Iran Cold War

Critic reviews

"Delicious mind candy." (Amazon.com)
"The book of the year for any history lover." (Kirkus Reviews)

People who viewed this also viewed...

What If? Part 1 Audiobook By Stephen E. Ambrose, John Keegan, more cover art
What If? Part 1 By: Stephen E. Ambrose, and others
What If? Audiobook By Christopher Andrew cover art
What If? By: Christopher Andrew
All stars
Most relevant  
The introduction to this second What If book promises to go beyond the first volume's war- and conflict-heavy focus on "counter-factual history."
As a genre of history writing, "counter-factual," or "what if" scenarios, are a particularly fun and engaging way of looking at events. The essays contained in this book are written by several different historians, each with their own style and approach.
They seem to work best when the authors truly explore the alternate scenario, providing a fantastical, narrative account - such as the counterfactual "history" of a world where the Chinese became a great seafaring empire, or if Jesus had been spared by Pontius Pilate.
Unfortutnately, the majority of the essays are written by authors who are brilliant historians, but hardly great writers. Military history, despite the promise of the introduction, still dominates the book. The final essay, a speculation on a world where the potato was never introduced to Europe, carries on for ages about facts and figures, and dwindles off in a weak afterthought, committing only the last very few seconds to the idea of a Europe without potatoes. It is as if the author of that final piece had been reminded right at the end what the thesis of this book was.
The most disappointing aspect of the audiobook, however, is the narrator himself. With a flat, dispassionate voice and mediocre sense of timing, Murphy Guyer comes across more like a high school teacher than a professional reader. His mangled pronunciation of Chinese names takes one of the best essays in the book down from gripping to merely bearable.
A shame, since the narrators of Volume I had done such a good job.
Worth the free download, but not up to the usual standards of Simon & Schuster Audio.

An interesting book tainted by a poor narrator

Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
There is no such thing as "counterfactual history": rather there is fiction that uses history as the grist for its mill. It is thus as fiction that one should judge "What If?," and as fiction it sucks. The volume starts with a curmudgeonly gripe about the professionalization of history in the academy. The first effort in the collection is an eye-rolling fantasy about Jesus and the crucifiction. The writer meanders through a muddle of gross characterizations about religion (it is "about" interpretation, we are told), then wanders through some cardboard set-pieces about Pontius Pilot. I found myself baffled and bored. I like history and attempts to think through the challenges of writing stories about a past from an available archive. I also like historical fiction: self-conscious novelizations of sometimes familiar and often unfamiliar characters that mean to illuminate another time, place, and people. I stopped listening about 45 minutes into the volume. I deleted the selection and plan to add something better written, or at least intellectually interesting, or both. Churlish defenses of the value of this type of enterprise are unconvincing, especially if the authors are unwilling to be explicit about how it is that the fiction that spins out of the phrase "What if?" might help us to understand "what was" and, ultimately, what could be.

Surprisingly amateurish, grating, and curmudgeonly

Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.