This week we’re looking at season 1, episode 3, “Dead* in the Water.” As Sam and Dean are “Movin’ On” from Colorado, they pause the search for their dad to take a case at a lake in Wisconsin where people keep mysteriously drowning. Dean bonds with a fellow traumatized child of a dead parent named Lucas, who doesn’t talk and constantly draws pictures related to the case. Dean tries to hit on Lucas’s hot mother Andrea, played by BtVS alum Amy Acker, before she nearly becomes the killer’s latest victim. Learn what classic rock band Dean thinks “rules,” what the Best Song of the episode is, and how Plushies would Make Everything Better in this week’s show.

“Dead in the Water” on Superwiki: http://www.supernaturalwiki.com/1.03_Dead_in_the_Water

If you’re listening to this on Stitcher, Google Play, or iTunes, then welcome to the Plushienatural family! In the meantime, you can find a permanent download link to this show at plushienatural.com/podcast. You can find Amanda on Twitter at @sinnerforhire and Dean at @deanwbear79. You can also find us on Facebook at http://facebook.com/plushienatural. For more awesome bonus content, check out our Patreon.

*Every single time I try to type this, it comes out “Dean in the Water,” which is not entirely inaccurate…