Very focused on wartime broadcasts

Although Wodehouse’s wartime broadcasts were the most significant event of his life and certainly shouldn’t be overlooked, I would have liked more about the times in which he lived. Written by a friend of the family, the book narrates the events of Plum’s life and analyzes his books, but gives no sense of, say, the New York theatre scene of the 1920s.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

A wonderful account that helps one to appreciate this gifted creator even more!!!

Wodehouse books are such a perfect diversion to keep ones mind in a sunny place!!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Nicely done, I suppose

Nicely done, I suppose. The book is nicely written but doesn’t grab me. The reading performance was professional and skillful in many ways. But, it constantly irritates me. I recommend the book because I recognize it’s good qualities and because it is the only biography Audible offers on P.G. Wodehouse.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Fascinating biography

Fascinating biography by a friend of Wodehouse's family. It's a bit quirky and idiosyncratic for a biography, but that's what makes it interesting. The narrator's exaggerated vocalizing is more than a little hard to get past, but i pressed through , got used to it and was glad because i enjoyed the book so much.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

An Appreciative Official Biography of Plum

What did you love best about P.G. Wodehouse?

Well read, fairly honest in its enthusiasm for Wodehouse, and surprisingly objective when it comes to the troublesome aspects of P.G.'s character and difficult periods of his life. The author was a friend of the family who knew PGW, and was also the daughter and biographer of playwright Frederick Lonsdale. This book makes a nice compliment to Robert McCrum's definitive biography of a few years ago. It does provide some greater detail to Plum's interment during WWII, including some lengthy excerpts of his camp journals, and does provide a longer treatment of this period, perhaps more artfully summarized in McCrum's book.

How would you have changed the story to make it more enjoyable?

There is an almost chronological review of PGW's writing and some commentary on books other than those most currently remembered (the Jeeves and Bertie series and the Blandings Castle stories).

Which character – as performed by Frederick Davidson – was your favorite?

Ms. Donaldson provides an objective, "insiders" view of PGW, and if she is forgiving of his eccentricities, she does deal with them in an objective, if generally sympathetic manner. The unfortunate episode and its aftermath does cast a kind of pall on the book, which is perhaps proportionate to its impact in PGW's life. But overall, Ms. Donaldson conveys the charmed life of a gifted and rightly celebrated writer. Because of the author's obvious affection for her subject, she does take the time and effort to go through the entirety of his career, including his work for the stage which is sometimes given short shrift.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

Like most of the Wodehouse audible releases, the performance is terrific, particularly when reciting excerpts from the Master's work. It was a bit strange at first, to hear a male voice narrating a book authored by a woman, but this worked as well, since there is a lot of recitation from PGW's work and his private correspondences.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

13 people found this helpful

very enjoyable

I skipped through some long parts, but really enjoyed it and learned alot about P.G.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Reader is unbearably humorless and pompous

I am a huge PG Wodehouse fan. I read his books over and over, always delighted by his comic writing. Yet I cannot get through more than 10 minutes at a time of this audio biography due to the appalling affect of the reader. Davidson is grating, unlikeable, and off putting. I would greatly prefer a robot reader to this disgraceful performance.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Enjoyable for Wodehouse fans

By the end of the book, I felt I had a sense of Wodehouse’s personality, not merely the facts of his life. The book ends abruptly with his death which felt unsatisfactory as I was curious about his wife’s life afterwards. Maybe I just didn’t want the story to end. I think this book will be most satisfactory to those who have read a good deal of P. G. Wodehouse’s writings and are familiar with English authors. A lot of time was spent on the war time, broadcasts and the aftermath, but that seems appropriate because that episode colored his life forever after. The results of this book will be to whet your appetite for reading and rereading his books.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Disappointing.

This book seems to breeze through the author's youth and beginnings as a writer, and is devoid of the humor found in other Wodehouse biographies. The story first two decades of Wodehouse's life were told so briefly that the book had the feeling of an abridged work. So much so, in fact, that I checked to see if it was an abridged production. (It isn't.)

Overall, I do not recommend.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

A Personal Take Rather Than a Scholarly Biography

According to Donaldson, works I esteem (A Gentleman of Leisure) fail to make “the first rank of the novels”; characters I should have shunned (Ukridge) I love; other characters I prize as exemplary effusions of the Master’s genius (Psmith) stand revealed as atypical impediments to Wodehouse’s development. A novel I adore (The Girl on the Boat) is really, “…one of the most unsatisfactory of all…with a slow-moving plot and not very much humor”. It’s embarrassing, like being caught using the fish fork for the entrée. One simply doesn’t know where to look.

But then, this is the work of a biographer who sat down and, it seems from her own testimony, plowed through Wodehouse’s more than 90 books, in order of publication, and then delivered her personal responses to them. A somewhat chatty, anecdotal book, I found very few instances of an insight that unlocked a deeper understanding of the man or his works. For that, you need to go to Robert McCrum's superb biography, Wodehouse: A Life (alas, not on Audible but a great paper-and-ink read).

Donaldson’s position as “authorized” biographer should prepare us for sympathetic treatment of her subject, and she handles the biggest mistake of Wodehouse’s life, the Berlin broadcasts, with even-handed intelligence. But it’s also the only period of his life she treats at length, and with some sense of chronology, giving an overall impression of lopsidedness. However, the scanty, debatable literary analysis remains the largest fly in this ointment. Frederick Davidson, one of my favorite readers of Wodehouse, does his usual superb job.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful