John XXIII, The Greatest Pope

Thomas Cahill situates John XXIII’s person and papacy within the history of the Roman Catholic Church as well as developments in the Church after John’s death. Cahill begins with a lengthy description of papal history up until John’s time. He then briefly introduces John’s family life and movement toward the throne in Rome. Cahill then treats in detail—complete with Vatican intrigues!—John’s greatest contribution to the Church, the Second Vatican Council. Finally, Cahill compares John’s papacy with that of his more conservative successors.

Cahill’s “dark history” of the papacy might offend some, but it is largely accurate. Indeed, Cahill offers some papal highlights amid all the gloom, most notably the reign of Gregory the Great. Any objective history of the papacy will turn up just as much dirt, maybe even more—papal executioners, concubines, wars, excesses, and so on.

As a contrast to much of this debauchery or well-intended inaction, Cahill offers the wise and compassionate papacy of John XXIII. His anecdotal history of John’s family life and struggles through the priesthood make for especially enjoyable and spiritual listening. Current world affairs make John’s lifelong commitment to peace resonant and urgent. John’s equanimity and focus on Jesus, while making his way through well-meaning, but closed-minded bureaucrats, also offers a model of sanctity and compassion in the midst of disagreement and misunderstanding.

“Conservative” Catholics will probably dislike this book. “Liberal” members will most likely nod along. And the open-minded will probably learn a few things about a remarkable man and a model of sainthood.

Also Recommended on Audible: Hans Kung, -The Catholic Church-

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

8 people found this helpful

Enlightening Biography

This is an enlightening and critical biography of John XXIII, providing a sketch of relevant papal history, a fetching portrait of John, the challenges of his momentous life, and his significant mark in history. The narration was perfectly suited. I wouldn't have minded if there was more about service in France as the papal nuncio after WWII, but there was enough to be intriguing.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Christ Bringing Redemption

It is important that we realize that Jesus Christ is God's ONLY begotten Son, and the rest of us, including the Pope and all clergy need regeneration and sanctification. If we keep that in mind, we can accept the humanity of the clergy, and not see them as having transcended the human condition, but rather are being redeemed by Jesus Christ like all other Christians. Jesus said, "upon this Rock, I will build my church." He is the one building. The sacraments are His grace to us, and the clergy are his ministers. That being said, it is essential that we look to Jesus Hebrews 12:2 "Let us fix our eyes on Jesus, the author and perfecter of our faith, who for the joy set before him endured the cross, scorning its shame, and sat down at the right hand of the throne of God." Keep in mind as you listen to this fine teaching that any history of the church will include the manward side, which is fallen man being redeemed. Though we know Divinity in the Eucharist, it is not from the priest, but from our faithful High Priest, Jesus Christ. The outworking of salvation will never look as pristine as the wonderful anointing that comes over the priest as Jesus makes present the Eucharist, the Bread of Heaven, His own Body and Blood for us, our Redeemer. We know His presence when we receive Holy Communion in a very special way, and we must never give credit for that to the priest, but to God alone. It is actually He that we commune with and Whose anointing we experience. Some reviewers do not like some of the facts of the leaders of the church, but those facts show up in all teachings to some degree, and should just be viewed as the manward, the side being redeemed.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Wonderful, inspiring!

Would you listen to Pope John XXIII again? Why?

Yes, for the information is provided and for the insight into the man. At this time we need more than ever a picture of a renewed and warm humanity.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

No ... I want to savor parts of it. It brought me down memory lane. It reminded me that hope is a choice you have to make; and joy is its promise.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Interesting take on other popes

It was an educational tour through popes preceding Pope John. I knew little about the earlier popes, but had read a few excellent books on this pope. What I was a bit astonished by was the harsh words for the popes who followed him.

I believe this is biased, though I very much enjoyed the account of Joh’s life and suffering. I have to disagree strongly on the author’s judgment of recent popes, and the anger expressed. Each of these men is holy in his own way. This does not give that impression.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Opinionated and important book

The writer leaves no doubt where he stands on the papacy and the modern Catholic Church in this bio of the man who may be the only believing Christian to ascend to the papacy.

The narrator does a great job telling the story. For once there are no faux accents when quoting sources from various countries and backgrounds.

Had he lived longer perhaps John XXIII would have transformed the Church into a better institution that would have met the needs of many more people across the world.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

It's not the sentimental

I'm a faithful Catholic (the kind who enjoys daily mass and my breviary), and I enjoyed every minute of this audiobook!

Perhaps the title ought to have reflected that much of the book contained histotrical context of the papacy, but folks! What else can be written about popes at a time when society was such that the papacy was more about polity than faith and morals? I don't think Cahill meant his work as definitive history of the Catholic Church - even Kung's much longer and more serious audiobook on the subject does not pretend to that. (That's also a pretty good listen, but not exactly "entertaining" as is Cahill's)

Cahill tells of the good news from Popes also - what there was - And he tells the whole tale with a dry humour (like the reference to Calvinist Geneva being "not much fun" alluded to above).

Cahill may have been too easy on John XXXIII, though - Surely no human could be that good - why he'd be a...saint?

Humorous, informative, inspiring, well narrated from a a well-written text, this audiobook goes particularly well accompanied by the autobiographies of Simone Veil, Dorothy Day, and Deitrich Bonhoeffer also available on this site.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

Consider the source

First the good. This book contains a reasonable and sympathetic portrait of John XXIII, his role in initiating the second Vatican council, and the council itself. As far as I know, there is nothing else like it on Audible.

Unfortunately this book's flaws overwhelm its virtues. The first couple of hours on the history of the papacy cast nearly everything about the church and the popes in a harshly negative light. It comes off as awesomely arrogant and judgmental, and unfair even where it is right.

Not being expert on that history, I decided to judge Cahill's judgment based on his treatment of the great John Paul II. In one word, it is SAVAGE. Huh????

Ignore this guy. He is not trustworthy.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

Extremely biased and one sided

The basics of the book is is that Christianity as a whole is ridiculous and the church is ran by a bunch of power hungry evil men (with the soul exception of John XXIII). the author greatly exaggerates the conservatism of all of the other popes and greatly exaggerates the liberalism of John XXIII. He takes quotes from other popes wildly out of contacts and tells an extremely biased view of history and fails to realize the complexity is that the popes and the church have faced. The narration was fantastic but if you really want to learn about John the XXIII or the church I recommend you go elsewhere

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Anti-Catholic or Completely Atheistic?

I got this book hoping to take a look at the life of Pope John XXIII, but instead I received a book that either has an anti-Catholic stance or was written from a completely atheistic point of view. Either way, the author here obviously shows the Catholic Church in an absolutely horrible light.

The book begins easily enough with a brief introduction of a few sayings of Pope John XXIII. The author then decides to update the reader on the history of the papal lines to give you some "background" as to the papacy that John XXXIII was entering into. What then proceeds from this is a two and a half hour diatribe on every bad thing every pope did up to the time of Pope John XXIII. The reader is left with a sense that every pope in the Catholic Church was driven by lust, power, or greed. Even the very rare instances where the author attempts to shine a good light on the papal reform, it is downplayed with comments to make the reader feel that his efforts were futile due to the corruption in the entire church.

Additionally, the "colorful" language of the book adds comments to fundamental Catholic doctrine as "off the wall" and "unbiblical". This is especially true when the doctrines of Marry the blessed mother of Jesus are mentioned. I also found it ironic that the book spends about 20 minutes on the protestant reformation and how Protestantism turned some towns into places of "not much fun".

If you are Catholic and are truly interested in church history, I highly suggest you pass this one by.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

22 people found this helpful