
Should Have Been Me
Pembrooke, Book 4
Failed to add items
Add to Cart failed.
Add to Wish List failed.
Remove from wishlist failed.
Adding to library failed
Follow podcast failed
Unfollow podcast failed

Get 2 free audiobooks during trial.
Buy for $19.95
No default payment method selected.
We are sorry. We are not allowed to sell this product with the selected payment method
-
Narrated by:
-
Andi Arndt
-
Christian Fox
-
By:
-
Jessica Prince
About this listen
She’s a sunny, sassy photographer.
Jolie Prescott has always been in love with love. She spent most of her life walking around with hearts in her eyes and immediately jumped at the chance to start a wedding planning company with her two best friends. So when her own fiancé called off their wedding and immediately started dating someone else, it was a major blow she never saw coming. The gossip about it finally starts to die down in her small town. Then her ex announced he’s engaged again. And his new fiancée just happens to be Jolie’s worst enemy. Which makes it really inconvenient that she can’t seem to stop thinking inappropriate thoughts about that woman’s moody half-brother.
He is the ultimate grump.
Vaughn Cavanagh never thought he’d set foot back in Pembrooke, Wyoming after moving away when he was thirteen, but when his father gets sick, he uproots his life to try to repair their frayed relationship. The only thing standing in his way is his spoiled brat half-sister, her determination to throw the ultimate wedding, and her beef with a certain wedding photographer he can’t get out of his head.
When one impulsive act leads to Vaughn announcing he and Jolie are dating, the two have no choice but to fake their relationship to save face. But when feelings enter the picture and lines start to blur, Vaughn has to decide if he’s willing to give up his quiet, solitary life and stay in Pembrooke for a woman he never intended to fall for, or if he’s going to risk losing everything because he’s too afraid to take that leap.
©2024 Jessica Prince Books LLC (P)2024 Jessica Prince Books LLCListeners also enjoyed...
-
Shattered Dreams
- A Small Town, Enemies to Lovers, Forbidden Romance (Dream Series)
- By: Natasha Madison
- Narrated by: Gregory Salinas, Savannah Peachwood
- Length: 8 hrs and 8 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
It was supposed to be a regular day out. Three couples celebrating the last days of summer. When tragedy struck. I thought I was going to marry her. Instead, I was burying her. I blamed the world for my pain. I buried it all. I became a man I didn’t even recognize.
-
-
Angsty Entertainment
- By Paige on 10-24-24
By: Natasha Madison
-
Sweet Sunshine
- The Pembrooke Series, Book 1
- By: Jessica Prince
- Narrated by: Angelina Rocca, Lee Samuels
- Length: 6 hrs and 47 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Chloe Delaney had three very specific wishes growing up. She wished to stay settled in the small mountain town of Pembrooke, where she grew up, to one day be her own boss, and to fall in love with a man who would be willing to go to the ends of the Earth for her. With her roots firmly planted in Pembrooke’s soil and her bakery, Sinful Sweets, thriving, two of her wishes have already come true. When a handsome single father moves to town, she’s certain she’s found the man to fill the role of wish number three. The only problem is that you can’t force a frog to turn into a prince.
-
-
Amazing story
- By lwmorrisonbooklover on 01-23-24
By: Jessica Prince
-
Long Time Coming
- A Small Town, Single Dad, Brother's Best Friend Ranch Romance
- By: S.L. Scott
- Narrated by: Samantha Summers, Ryan Hudson
- Length: 11 hrs and 9 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
It didn’t take long for news to spread that Tagger Grange was back in Peachtree Pass. I found out even faster when I fell right into his arms—not by choice. The barstool wobbled under me when reaching for a cheddar biscuit. They’re my weakness. Much like he used to be. Rolled up sleeves and tailored pants have replaced the boots and jeans my brother’s best friend once wore. But it’s not just the clothes that have changed. His shoulders are broader and he’s broodier. Somehow, he's even more handsome than ever.
-
-
Boring and trite
- By Guntergirl on 05-22-25
By: S.L. Scott
-
See It Through
- A Small Town, Brother's Best Friend Romance (The Kelly Ranch)
- By: Julia Wolf
- Narrated by: Emma Wilder, Sean Masters
- Length: 9 hrs and 27 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
This house isn't big enough for the both of us... As my older brother’s best friend, Remington Town used to be like a member of my family. But the minute he turned eighteen, he left our small town of Sugar Brush, Wyoming and never looked back. Thirteen years later, Remi shows up to settle his father’s estate, but as far as I’m concerned, he should’ve stayed gone. Besides, he’s in for a big surprise when he finds out the old farmhouse he intends to sell is now half mine. I expect him to pack up and leave again, but this time, he’s in no hurry to hit the road.
-
-
Small town
- By Brittney on 05-05-25
By: Julia Wolf
-
Pretend We Are Us
- The Timberbridge Brothers, Book 1
- By: Claudia Burgoa
- Narrated by: Erin Mallon, Aaron Shedlock
- Length: 7 hrs and 5 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I never expected to inherit a sprawling estate in a small town I’d never even heard of. To claim it, I have to outmaneuver my scheming cousin and fulfill one impossible condition: Find a groom. Enter Ledger Timberbridge—the infuriatingly charming stranger I crossed paths with on my solo (read: canceled) honeymoon. Now, he’s here in Birchwood Springs, fighting to save his family’s struggling logging company. And somehow, he’s probably my only shot at keeping my inheritance.
-
-
Ledger & Gale, Timberbridge Brothers, book 1
- By Sherry on 05-30-25
By: Claudia Burgoa
-
Mad Love
- The Single Dad Playbook, Book 1
- By: Willow Aster
- Narrated by: Ava Erickson, Connor Crais
- Length: 7 hrs and 53 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
For a long time now, I’ve despised Weston Shaw. He’d been someone I’d admired, taking my favorite football team, the Colorado Mustangs, to the Super Bowl. But that all turned upside down after one night that had nothing to do with me. We share one undeniable connection: his son, Caleb. Unfortunately, the circumstances behind that have never been my story to tell. But now, the truth is out, and I’m left to deal with the consequences. I’m living under the same roof as Weston, and each day, I discover a side of him I never expected.
-
-
Sweet Single Dad Romance
- By @mellovesaudiobooks - IG on 10-11-24
By: Willow Aster
-
Shattered Dreams
- A Small Town, Enemies to Lovers, Forbidden Romance (Dream Series)
- By: Natasha Madison
- Narrated by: Gregory Salinas, Savannah Peachwood
- Length: 8 hrs and 8 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
It was supposed to be a regular day out. Three couples celebrating the last days of summer. When tragedy struck. I thought I was going to marry her. Instead, I was burying her. I blamed the world for my pain. I buried it all. I became a man I didn’t even recognize.
-
-
Angsty Entertainment
- By Paige on 10-24-24
By: Natasha Madison
-
Sweet Sunshine
- The Pembrooke Series, Book 1
- By: Jessica Prince
- Narrated by: Angelina Rocca, Lee Samuels
- Length: 6 hrs and 47 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Chloe Delaney had three very specific wishes growing up. She wished to stay settled in the small mountain town of Pembrooke, where she grew up, to one day be her own boss, and to fall in love with a man who would be willing to go to the ends of the Earth for her. With her roots firmly planted in Pembrooke’s soil and her bakery, Sinful Sweets, thriving, two of her wishes have already come true. When a handsome single father moves to town, she’s certain she’s found the man to fill the role of wish number three. The only problem is that you can’t force a frog to turn into a prince.
-
-
Amazing story
- By lwmorrisonbooklover on 01-23-24
By: Jessica Prince
-
Long Time Coming
- A Small Town, Single Dad, Brother's Best Friend Ranch Romance
- By: S.L. Scott
- Narrated by: Samantha Summers, Ryan Hudson
- Length: 11 hrs and 9 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
It didn’t take long for news to spread that Tagger Grange was back in Peachtree Pass. I found out even faster when I fell right into his arms—not by choice. The barstool wobbled under me when reaching for a cheddar biscuit. They’re my weakness. Much like he used to be. Rolled up sleeves and tailored pants have replaced the boots and jeans my brother’s best friend once wore. But it’s not just the clothes that have changed. His shoulders are broader and he’s broodier. Somehow, he's even more handsome than ever.
-
-
Boring and trite
- By Guntergirl on 05-22-25
By: S.L. Scott
-
See It Through
- A Small Town, Brother's Best Friend Romance (The Kelly Ranch)
- By: Julia Wolf
- Narrated by: Emma Wilder, Sean Masters
- Length: 9 hrs and 27 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
This house isn't big enough for the both of us... As my older brother’s best friend, Remington Town used to be like a member of my family. But the minute he turned eighteen, he left our small town of Sugar Brush, Wyoming and never looked back. Thirteen years later, Remi shows up to settle his father’s estate, but as far as I’m concerned, he should’ve stayed gone. Besides, he’s in for a big surprise when he finds out the old farmhouse he intends to sell is now half mine. I expect him to pack up and leave again, but this time, he’s in no hurry to hit the road.
-
-
Small town
- By Brittney on 05-05-25
By: Julia Wolf
-
Pretend We Are Us
- The Timberbridge Brothers, Book 1
- By: Claudia Burgoa
- Narrated by: Erin Mallon, Aaron Shedlock
- Length: 7 hrs and 5 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I never expected to inherit a sprawling estate in a small town I’d never even heard of. To claim it, I have to outmaneuver my scheming cousin and fulfill one impossible condition: Find a groom. Enter Ledger Timberbridge—the infuriatingly charming stranger I crossed paths with on my solo (read: canceled) honeymoon. Now, he’s here in Birchwood Springs, fighting to save his family’s struggling logging company. And somehow, he’s probably my only shot at keeping my inheritance.
-
-
Ledger & Gale, Timberbridge Brothers, book 1
- By Sherry on 05-30-25
By: Claudia Burgoa
-
Mad Love
- The Single Dad Playbook, Book 1
- By: Willow Aster
- Narrated by: Ava Erickson, Connor Crais
- Length: 7 hrs and 53 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
For a long time now, I’ve despised Weston Shaw. He’d been someone I’d admired, taking my favorite football team, the Colorado Mustangs, to the Super Bowl. But that all turned upside down after one night that had nothing to do with me. We share one undeniable connection: his son, Caleb. Unfortunately, the circumstances behind that have never been my story to tell. But now, the truth is out, and I’m left to deal with the consequences. I’m living under the same roof as Weston, and each day, I discover a side of him I never expected.
-
-
Sweet Single Dad Romance
- By @mellovesaudiobooks - IG on 10-11-24
By: Willow Aster
-
Stay Toxic
- Semyonov Bratva, Book 1
- By: Lani Lynn Vale
- Narrated by: Tieran Wilder, J.T. Londale
- Length: 5 hrs and 44 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
There was right, there was wrong, and then there was the in-between. The place where normal people reside, understanding that there are two sides to every coin. People that do bad things for good reasons. People that do bad things for bad reasons. First, I knew that Shasha Semyonov was a bad man. One that did bad things for bad reasons. That didn’t mean that I was rational when it came to him.
-
-
Awesome start to a new series!
- By Cody Gates on 01-09-25
By: Lani Lynn Vale
-
Stepbrother Dearest
- By: Penelope Ward
- Narrated by: Andi Arndt, Christian Fox
- Length: 7 hrs and 58 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
When my stepbrother, Elec, came to live with us my senior year, I wasn’t prepared for how much of a jerk he’d be. I hated that he took it out on me because he didn’t want to be here. I hated that he brought girls from our high school back to his room. But what I hated the most was the unwanted way my body reacted to him. At first, I thought all he had going for him were his rock-hard tattooed abs and chiseled face. But things started changing between us, and it all came to a head one night.
-
-
Perfection!!
- By Amazon Customer on 01-18-25
By: Penelope Ward
-
One Last Summer
- Plain Daisy Ranch
- By: Piper Rayne
- Narrated by: CJ Bloom, Robert Hatchet
- Length: 56 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
He's my first love. My high school sweetheart. And he's leaving tomorrow for a bigger and better life. I've loved Ben almost my entire life, and we have one night left before he heads miles away to college on a football scholarship. I'm bound and determined to make sure this day goes perfectly so he remembers me as the girl he loves. But I cant help worrying that Ill end up as the girl he loved.
-
-
🥵
- By Brie on 05-22-25
By: Piper Rayne
-
Beautiful Crazy
- A Small Town Single Mom Romance (Blossom Beach, Book 1)
- By: A. James
- Narrated by: Connor Crais, Samantha Brentmoor
- Length: 8 hrs and 20 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
As a single mom with my hands and heart full, finding love is the last thing on my mind. Then Everett Windward comes along. My new neighbor is charming, handsome, and sexy—and before I know it, I have a new friend…with benefits. Fun and filthy benefits. There’s just one problem—He’s also my son’s teacher. That alone should have me pumping the brakes… except it doesn’t. I’m drawn to him and to the way he makes me feel. Everett has a filthy side that has reignited something inside of me that I haven’t felt in years.
-
-
Brentmoor & Crais Sizzle in DUET Narration! 🔥+🌶
- By Sherry on 01-06-25
By: A. James
-
All Too Well
- By: Corinne Michaels
- Narrated by: Vanessa Edwin, Connor Crais
- Length: 8 hrs and 48 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
For as long as I can remember, Lachlan West has been my brother’s best friend and the love of my life. Trouble is, he kissed me four years ago and then never spoke to me again. I was doing great pretending he doesn’t exist until I was assigned to write an article about former college athletes and I learn that the sexy single-dad is my first interview. Determined to wow my editor with an amazing sportsball piece. (Have I mentioned I know nothing about sports?) I head to Ember Falls, ready to face my fears—and the man I love.
-
-
Dumb FMC
- By Cara on 10-04-24
By: Corinne Michaels
-
Sacrifice
- By: Adriana Locke
- Narrated by: Joe Arden, Maxine Mitchell
- Length: 9 hrs and 37 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
After losing her husband in a tragic accident, Julia Gentry is barely surviving. Raising her young daughter alone takes everything she has—and that’s not enough. She’s barely making ends meet. And then tragedy strikes again. Julia’s only hope lies in the last place she wants to look—in Crew Gentry. Her husband’s brother is broody. Irresponsible. He’s broken her heart more than once and let her down every time she’s needed him.
-
-
Such a beautiful story
- By Judy Portelles on 02-19-24
By: Adriana Locke
-
Until It Was Love
- By: Pippa Grant
- Narrated by: Samantha Brentmoor, Jason Clarke
- Length: 10 hrs and 3 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
There are a million reasons why I shouldn’t date Fletcher Huxley. He’s a growly-faced, stubborn-streaked, international rugby legend trying to revive his flailing career in the US after being canned by his team overseas. While he might have the good kind of thunder thighs, intriguing tattoos, and a booty of steel, he also holds the top position on my very short nemesis list thanks to what happened the first time we met.
-
-
Is it all about the moustache?
- By Kristi Sam on 04-25-24
By: Pippa Grant
-
Steal My Heart
- Rosewood River Series, Book 1
- By: Laura Pavlov
- Narrated by: Andi Arndt, Connor Crais
- Length: 9 hrs
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Henley Holloway is my boss’s daughter, and I’ve been assigned to mentor her. The problem is, I’m not looking to babysit anyone. But I’m determined to make partner at the firm, and this is the final obstacle in my way. So, I agree to take the little princess under my wing. I’ll work her so hard, she’ll beg me to leave her alone. But from the first day she walks into the office and spills scalding hot coffee on my chest—I’m intrigued.
-
-
Easton and Henley🩷
- By Judy Portelles on 01-13-25
By: Laura Pavlov
-
The Little Things
- Second Hope, Book 1
- By: Jessica Prince
- Narrated by: Ava Erickson, Rock Engle
- Length: 7 hrs and 35 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I’ll admit, I made more than my fair share of stupid decisions, but all it took was an accidental felony and a teensy kitchen fire to turn my life upside down. When my parents cut me off, selling my swanky Los Angeles apartment and shipping me off to some ranch in the middle of nowhere to teach me a lesson, I thought it was the worst thing that could happen to me. Then I got to Safe Haven Ranch and met my new boss.
By: Jessica Prince
-
The Way We Touch
- A Small-Town, Brother’s Best Friend Sports Romance (The Bradford Boys, Book 1)
- By: Tia Louise
- Narrated by: Connor Crais, Samantha Brentmoor
- Length: 8 hrs and 56 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Logan Murphy should come with a warning. He’s as hot as a Carolina Reaper on black asphalt in the middle of July. With perfectly messy dark hair and smoldering blue eyes—and don’t even get me started on the way that black tee stretches across his toned chest… He’s my brother’s best friend. He’s also a football star on track to win the first wide-receiver MVP in league history. Good thing I only date golfers… or I did.
-
-
Logan "Lightning" Murphy was Hot!
- By Sherry on 08-08-24
By: Tia Louise
-
Finding Home
- By: Lauren Rowe
- Narrated by: Andi Arndt, Sean Masters
- Length: 11 hrs and 9 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I’m Caleb “C-Bomb” Baumgarten, the bad boy drummer of Red Card Riot. After tragedy strikes, I get the bright idea to hire my daughter’s remaining lifeline, her “Auntie Aubbey,” as my live-in nanny in her small town. I’m determined not to give in to my white-hot attraction to Aubrey, since I need her to certify my sobriety and testify on my behalf at an upcoming custody hearing. But you know what they say about best laid plans, right? Yeah. My bad.
-
-
Loved it
- By Judy Portelles on 03-07-25
By: Lauren Rowe
-
Tame the Heart
- Runaway Ranch, Book 1
- By: Ava Hunter
- Narrated by: CJ Bloom, Teddy Hamilton
- Length: 11 hrs and 34 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Charlie Montgomery is one grumpy rancher. Calloused hands, stubborn heart, the definition of a true cowboy. He dislikes me from the second we meet. Warns me away from his tiny town of Resurrection, Montana. Well, what he doesn't know is I'm armed with a bucket list and a secret. There's no way I'm leaving. I'll just keep my distance. Only in a small town that distance doesn’t last for long. Because I owe him a favor: Work for him for three months and help him save his home. Runaway Ranch. But our close confines mean I see what's under all that strong. I see the real Charlie Montgomery.
-
-
Fantastic Narration
- By Mysti Ubeda on 05-30-25
By: Ava Hunter
Well, she was right. He is amazing!
This was a small town story about a photographer who takes photos of everyone else’s HEA without finding her own and a grumpy, broody billionaire who doesn’t even consider touching love with a ten-foot pole. Well, the joke’s on him, I guess.
Vaughn moves back to his home town of Pembrooke because of his sick father. He doesn’t really want to be here, to be fair, and it doesn’t help that one day he almost runs over a cat, which, of course, belongs to Jolie. To be fair, it’s a pretty funny meet cute—especially if you are or have been a cat owner. I’m sure you’ll be able to relate.
Let’s just say they’re not each other’s biggest fans after that.
Jolie has been through a nasty breakup, and her ex is giving her a hard time—until Vaughn steps up. After claiming her with a kiss in front of the whole town, what else can they do but keep up the ruse and enter a fake relationship?
This was a fast-paced story, and if there’s something I love, it’s slowly seeing both main characters open up to each other. Christian’s voice is absolutely what I needed when it comes to portraying the seemingly detached, asshole-y Vaughn, who turns out to have more layers than expected, and Andi is perfect as the take-no-prisoners, strong, sunshiny heroine Jolie is from the start.
And… Can we talk about that driveway scene? Because that was hot!
They have some things to work out when it comes to what this thing between them is, and it’s worse when the whole town—because that’s a small town for you—is privy to their business. Do they get there in the end? They do, and let me tell you that Christian Fox handles groveling quite well too.
If you’re looking for a sweet yet sexy romance, take a chance on this audio. You won’t regret it!
Sweet and sexy small-town romance
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.