Tightly wrought unflashy character driven

In this Richard Fordesque novel, Nickolas Butler has given us a tightly woven, character driven novel, a novel that begins in 1962, takes an interlude in 1996, and then finishes in 2019. This is about heroism, family, friendship, love. The story may not be flashy or exciting but it is definitely very instructive, there is wisdom here. The narrative performance was decent as the baritone voice had trouble modulating multiple male voices, some which sounded like radio announcers.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Eagle Scout

As an Eagle Scout that grew up in Scouting during the 70's & 80's this book truly touched me. I could see a lot of my Scouting days in the stories. This book tugged really hard on my heart strings. I could relate to the camp Ranger as in my day I spent a lot of time with him helping him with the never ending things that needed repairs or installation. The other thing that I could relate to is the heard of white deer, for us it was several bobcats that the previous Ranger had raised because they had been abandoned. We would come across them all the time. How we knew that it was them is they would allow us to get within 10 feet before they would stand up and casually walk off into the thicket. Too many great memories were reopened for me.
Thank You
JSerow
Eagle Class of '83

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Enjoyed the story but the narrator

The characters and story kept my interest; however, I did not care for the narration which was affected, forced and overly dramatic.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Sad, but not hopeless

I almost stopped listening to this one in the opening chapters, because it was just so sad (I was aching for Nelson and his desire for friends ), and also during a truely awful scene between rival scout troops. So glad I stuck with it - credit the excellent narration and the good writing - because I really liked this character-based story.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

The heart is a lonely hunter

We’ve all experienced hard times. But never like these literary characters. It’s life in the first person.
A well woven and written narrative that will have you thanking the Higher Power for our indomitable spirit.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Relived my summers at Camp Napi in Montana!

I am an Eagle Scout (for the past 5 decades). This story broke my heart. I cried-I laughed-I thought of old friends-some alive-some long dead. But mainly I thought of those glorious summer weeks spent on St. Mary's Lake in NW Montana at CAMP NAPI as a young Boy Scout. Much of what the author expresses is darker than I recall it. But there is the heart of the truth in every bit of this story. I was especially touched by the description of the funeral scenes. I cannot tell you how many times I have stood at the coffins of the great men who were my Scout Leaders and wept for their passing. They were a truly rare breed and their kind will not pass this way again! I will listen to this story every summer for the rest of my life! If you were a Scout and spent time at a BSA summer Camp-I encourage you to listen to this story!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A Better Title would be "The Dark Hearts of Men"

I approached this novel expecting it to be a departure from the all-too-common contemporary fiction theme of men as brutish louts. That expectation arose from the title, the fact that Boy Scouting seemed to be the background framework of the plot, that the author is a man, and the descriptions and reviews of the book. While the book is a gripping story, or contains such within it, I found it a disappointing depiction of Boy Scouting and of boys and men in general. Most of the boys and men are people I would never want to know or be around; they fit the stereotype of male brutish louts who are also sex-obsessed, bullying, misogynistic and cowardly. However, I'm sure some will point out that there are some "points of light" in the story, some boys and men who stand out as exceptional, courageous, even heroic. So it seems--until and unless you take a closer look at them. The major character of the book is a bullied Boy Scout who has good character and eventually becomes the Scoutmaster of the camp. I suspect the author and some readers think he's a truly good man, but there is one very long scene where he condones and even seems to encourage the corruption of a young boy with alcohol and sex--even when the boy resists (at first). This very long, too detailed scene in the middle of the book really disappointed me and made me wonder about the author's view of what an exceptionally good-hearted man would do in such a situation. It colored my whole view of the one seemingly consistently good-hearted man in the whole story. The final portion of the novel is about a woman, a mother of a Boy Scout, who is made to feel unwelcome at her son's Boy Scout camp by the Scouts' fathers. I wondered how welcome a father would be at a Girl Scout camp. Well, I don't know, but it was a question that should at least have been brought up by someone in the very long argument in which she was made to feel more than unwelcome by the loutish, brutish, misogynistic, mouth-breathing fathers (without exception). Overall I rate this a potentially good story spoiled, for me, anyway, by the over riding theme of the dark hearts of boys and men.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

I cannot recommend this one

The story is quite contrived, and for various reasons just doesn't work very well. The men were mostly misogynistic pigs. Nelson comes off as a decent guy, but he is not a realistic character. The younger Trevor and even younger Thomas are portrayed as good male characters, but they are they only ones, and they are not drawn as human beings one would recognize. As an older white male, I know that there are quite a few men like those pictured in the story, but I did not grow up with and have not worked with such assholes, at least as far as I have been able to ascertain. In any event, I don't particularly want to read about the behavior of these kinds of guys. If this is intended to be a portrait of rotten male thinking and behavior, I can buy that, but it just isn't done very well. Although there are occasional bits of good writing, the writing overall is just not that good. I read this for my book club, and was so eager for it to end. Nikolas Butler may have written much better books than this, but I am unlikely to try them. And the narration does not help at all. The narrator might be able to do a single character well, but he struggles to perform the voice of multiple characters. His performance was quite affected and just not believable overall.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Just a Bad book!

Would you try another book from Nickolas Butler and/or Adam Verner?

This no. The Narrator is fine.

What could Nickolas Butler have done to make this a more enjoyable book for you?

This author thinks that morality is passe. He mocks Scouting, fatherhood and any kind of moral code to live buy. He paints fathers with no morals, and telling there sons that " if it feels good do it" no matter what the consequences are.

Which character – as performed by Adam Verner – was your favorite?

Nelson

What reaction did this book spark in you? Anger, sadness, disappointment?

I feel sorry for that author, he must of have a bad childhood. He show disdain for anyone with morals. It "ok" to cheat on your spouse, have sex with prostitutes. And to tell your son that it ok to be selfish.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

I really hated this book and the narration....

so contrived, predicable, melodramatic and pseudo-moralistic.

the narrator was just downright irritating. The voicing he did for the lead character of the grown up Nelson sounded like the voice you might hear in a 1950-something "educational" film. It was almost comical.

I kept listening to it with same curiosity I might derive from watching a really bad movie, wondering if this could really get worse. It did! By the half way point, I speeded the narration up to 1.5 which is something i have never done before

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!