wonderful

loved it all - book and narration. I enjoyed this rendition so very much. thank you

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Like Fine Wine

I've read this book 5 or 6 times now and it only gets better and better. There are so many nuances and depths to be discovered that it is like a bottomless well. The narration is so well done that it becomes transparent as it brings to life Katherine and Christopher and all the folk of the Gard and the Hill.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Amazing book but odd reader choices

The Perilous Gard might be my favorite book of all time, so if you’re wondering whether you should choose this audiobook based on the story, you absolutely should. It’s exquisite, understated historical fiction of the highest quality, with an admirable and believable heroine, a living and breathing sense of place and time, pristine historical detail—I can’t recommend it enough.

This reader has a very fine voice herself—a suitable English accent and genteel delivery—and she does solid and subtle voice-work for most characters, but there are many times when she misses an internal stage direction or the nuances of the dialogue. For example, when Kate says something “bemusedly,” “dully,” or “angrily,” the narrator often delivers it without the appropriate tone; the contrast is jarring. And there are rhythms and repetitions to Pope’s writing that this reader doesn’t pick up on at all. The audio quality is also iffy since this was digitized somehow from cassette—there’s a quiet but distracting echo at times, and at the end, the sound is muffled (but intelligible).

If it’s a choice between this audiobook and not taking the change to hear this exceptional story, you must choose the audiobook. But it’s perhaps high time for a new version.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

I wish I wrote this book!

it's wonderfully imaginative, but the world the author creates is beautifully grounded in the historical era of Queens Mary and Elizabeth, and in the lovely English countryside.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Reader is fabulous.

Perfectly written. A hidden gem that shouldn’t be. This story has intrigue, romance, adventure and the language is exquisite.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Note:I'm biased - I knew I loved the book going in

I am an avid reader of YA books - being of the opinion that they are generally better written and edited (being aimed at younger, more malleable minds seems to mean editors are more diligent about searching out typos - which throw me out of written books like a catapult. There are certainly exceptions to this rule, however.), and am always on the lookout for those books that contain female protagonists. Especially ones that don't fall into the typical damsel tropes. Here Elizabeth Marie Pope succeeded incredibly well. I adore Kate, and her pragmatic and logical view. It might not be the most in character for the typical girl her age, but it worked for me.

The book on a whole is very well written, and the atmosphere is very well-crafted. This is a WELL WRITTEN and WELL RESEARCHED book, and the category shouldn't chase off anyone. Truly, it's that good. The plot is slow to start, but the book is well - if deliberately, paced.

The reader is quite fitting and suits the style of writing very well. Kate doesn't sound like a flighty kid, and I was never jarred in my listening of a book I already knew very well.

I can't recommend this enough - although, to be honest, I think the print form is slightly more of a winner here, the audible is wonderful as well.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Amazing!

The way the way Jill Tanner reads this book drags you into the story so you never want it to end!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Over and Over

I've been listening to audiobooks for a long time now, but I rarely listen to one more than once. This is an exception. I could listen to this over and over again (and I have). I love this story. Kate Sutton is an excellent heroine. She's strong and smart, but she makes mistakes. The author spends the perfect amount of time on description. Her characters and her settings spring to life in my mind. I own a hard copy of this book, too, because I love it so much, but Jill Tanner's narration is so good. I had listened to this book before I read it for the first time, and I was afraid I wouldn't like the book as much as I liked the audio because the audio is so fantastic. Oftentimes for me, great audio covers up flaws in the writing, but this book combines a fabulous book with a wonderful narrator.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

I’ve loved this book since I was a child

I’ve read this book a thousand times. I’ve listened to it even more than that. This was my favorite book as a kid. I stumbled upon it by accident in my neighborhood library and I read it at least three or four times a year. There are a couple of places where the recording was a little garbled and a couple of spots where I would have read the inflection differently but I love this book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Did you have a perfect sister?

This is an especially suitable book for readers who ever felt awkward and inferior to a sister who seemed to bask in favor from all sides. I first read it as an adult and was captivated by the characters and the parallel worlds of flesh-and-blood Elizabethan intrigue, and a fantastic underworld.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!