Speaker details a dire situation where Phoenix pursues them to a cabin. Although initially restrained, Phoenix's malicious presence looms as they both plan a dangerous confrontation with Dana and Michael. After various violent interactions and codependent plans, Speaker A realizes their hope for a peaceful resolution is bleak and fears they might not survive the night, given Phoenix’s unpredictability and ruthless tactics.

Speaker shares a chilling account of waking up with a mannequin-like face, similar to Phoenix. Phoenix reveals a dark past involving a ritual to transfer his deceased sister Marlene's face onto him, which gruesomely backfired. Eerie knocking sounds plague their haven, escalating the tension. Phoenix irrationally advises hiding during the knocks, leading Speaker A to question the invisible threats and reflect on the concealed secrets, notably the forbidden freezer that might be hiding a dark revelation.

Ryan recalls a nocturnal escape orchestrated by a faceless man named Phoenix. They slipped out of Dana and Michael's house under the cover of darkness. As they travel a country road, Phoenix stops a car, incapacitates the driver, and forces Ryan to "borrow" the face of the female passenger. This transformation, lasting about 10 hours, terrifies Ryan. Phoenix introduces himself and drives them to a secluded log cabin with ominous instructions about not letting anyone in and drops the unconscious couple at a nearby rest stop, emphasizing the trust Ryan must place in him.

This episode features two chilling tales—Speaker A narrowly avoids a deadly accident due to a mysterious pager call, leading them to question if it was mere coincidence or something more. Then, Speaker B recounts their childhood fear of a basement ghost, only to later discover a man had been living undetected in their home. Both stories delve into the fine line between the paranormal and very real dangers in everyday life.

Journey into the eerie forests of the Northwest U.S. as we recount a 1992 search and rescue mission for a missing man and his grandson. Amidst mysterious "wolf whistles" and unexplainable sightings, this episode explores the unnerving and unresolved case. Listeners will be left pondering the strange wilderness phenomena and the lingering questions surrounding the disappearances.

In this episode, we retell a childhood horror story where a young child, left alone in a ground-floor apartment, encounters a stranger trying to break in. The discovery of a recently taken photograph of the child asleep in their bed turns a frightening situation into a deeply disturbing one. The story highlights the thin line between fictional horror and real-life terror, leaving a lasting impact on those who hear it.

This episode takes you to a rural East Texas farmhouse where the narrator experiences a night of eerie occurrences. After visiting their grandmother, who lives alone with their brother, they sense something off. The brother's encounter with a silent, menacing intruder raises questions about what or who was prowling around the property. Discover the unsettling details of this rural encounter and the broader implications for family safety in isolated areas.

Join us as we explore a spine-chilling nighttime encounter experienced by two siblings on an elementary school playground. A seemingly innocuous evening outing turns into a terrifying ordeal when they realize a man in a trench coat is throwing rocks from the school roof. The episode captures the raw fear and the race to safety, serving as a cautionary tale about how harmless pranks can have serious emotional impacts.