A fascinating look at what could have been.

Experiencing this original draft of this classic Star Trek episode "The City on the edge of Forever" was quite interesting in and of itself, but all the supplementary material was fascinating. (to use a Spock term) It's a journey into, not only an alternate world where a markedly different version of the story took place , but a journey into the behind the scenes drama trying to get the story finished and produced. Writer Harlan Ellison's frustration at all the rewrites he was forced to do and subsequent drafts without him are understandable when one reads (or hears in this case) his first draft. Though I still enjoy the televised version, I can now see the greater strengths In his untouched work. Besides this, is the story of Harlan's feud with Gene Roddenberry over the whole affair and his surprising bad treatment by Gene in later years for no good reason. I'm glad Harlan finally got to tell his version of the story on both accounts. It's well worth a listen or a read!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

The real reading starts in chapter 5.

Chapters 1 through 4 are endless complaining and airing of behind the scenes fighting. Chapter 5 is where you start the readings of the various versions of the script. Chapters 1 through 4 get only 1 star. 5 stars for the rest of the book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

You aren't buying this for what you think you are buying it for...

No, while Harlan Ellison's original screenplay is poignant, poetic, and beautiful, what you are actually buying this for is listen, spellbound, as Harlan spends literally hours eviscerating all those who have wronged him in the past. Of course this is primarily Gene RoddenbJerry, but also those that supported him. These parts are actually recorded by Ellison and you can feel the relish in his voice as he sets the record straight, and he has receipts. It's classic Ellison. I imagine he must have been a very hard man to be friends with, but he is certainly an incredibly gifted, if cantankerous, writer.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

I Have Two Ears and I Must Applaud

I'd forgotten from half a century ago how overwhelmingly enamoured I was of Ellison's virtually inimitable verbal virtuosity, his prodigiously creative imagination, the gut-wrenching poignancy of many of his stories (and even the combination of analytical rigor and hysterical humor that pervaded his television reviews in both volumes of "The Glass Teat").

But now I remember, and having listened to this entrancing and eloquently narrated account of the truth about the appalling treatment of his original (and brilliant) script for "The City on the Edge of Forever," I can well understand some of the inspired mordancy of his reviews of television shows no more in the league of his own "dangerous visions," than Danielle Steel is in the league of James Joyce -- which is not even to insult Danielle Steel, because it was never her intent to produce timeless works of genius. Ellison, IMHO, produced virtually nothing else.

This is the best audio book to which I've listened in perhaps two years.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Star Trek was not worthy of Ellison

A pleasure to revisit the original screenplay of this classic Trek episode. While considered by many Trekkies to be the best of the original 79 episodes, this version could have been one of the greatest Science Fiction achievements in TV history. The depth, heart and visual concepts presented dwarf by comparison the final product shown to audiences. It makes me laugh that so many people hate the "space pirates" bit (a vehicle for Rand so she would be more than eye candy) - even though it's basically the prototype for the beloved Mirror Universe that first manifested 6 months later. The original concept for the Guardians of Forever is so much cooler, and the excised plight of forgotten war veteran Trooper is heart breaking.. Great to hear the voice of the late, great Ellison again, too.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Interesting twist

I enjoy Harkin Ellison, I am a big Star Trek fan. It was nice to hear the original version of this story. I really could have done without all the whining, blaming and shaming that preceded the storytelling. REALLY! Can one be that petty? Enjoy the tale and skip the introduction.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

An absolute joy to listen to!

If you could sum up The City on the Edge of Forever in three words, what would they be?

Passionate, morally complex.

What other book might you compare The City on the Edge of Forever to and why?

None. Harlan Ellison is one of a kind.

Which scene was your favorite?

When Spock at the end tells Kirk that "No woman was ever loved as much Jim, because no woman was ever offered the universe for love."

If you were to make a film of this book, what would the tag line be?

Better then the original aired episode, buy your ticket now!

Any additional comments?

Enjoyed so much about this audio book:
Ellison reading his own delightfully candid introduction.
The full cast giving life to the Award Winning Teleplay.

Mostly it's just having this treasure on audio.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

5 Stars Really? for this belly full of kavetching?

well...yes.

if there is one thing Harlan Ellison is good

at,   it's being pissed off.


I own the neigh definitive Ellison collection.  He is a genius. 
He's hard core.  
Passionate.

Driven.  

Rebellious.
Ellison seems a man perpetually on a mission. 


I've listened to him read his own work, 
**NO ONE ELSE SHOULD READ ELLISON BUT ELLISON.**

enjoyed the result of his consult in Babylon 5, and faithfully watched ALL of the Sci-fi Channel's (that's SCI-FI, not sy-fy)  Sci-Fi Buzz commentaries. 


Preface to sayng...he is now older than dirt...and pissed off to an order of magnitude appropriate to time for said experiences in culminated in this iconic brand of pissed-off-ed-ness.


This missive is drowning in epic pissed-off-ed-ness.



 To call this a "rant" would be to diminish the intensity of the epic pissed-off-ed-ness for which Ellison is known.

From his first statement read himself,  it is evident,  this has been a point of contention. ... for a VERY long time. 


 1966 was a fair piece ago. 

 This reader was but 7 years of age... and Star Trek was the best thing on television, and City on the Edge of Forever was the best of the best. 

That's a long time to be ticked...and in his intro, it ALL comes boiling over. 

Couldn't he just give us the facts and story without the tirade?

Just the info without ripping the collective guilty to shreds in bloody spectacle of enraged verbosity?


If he did, it wouldn't be Ellison. 

...and we wouldn't care to read / listen to it. 

It's a long time to hold the grudge. 

Today, 30 years after the fact, Ellison is older than dirt and still above it.

His diction is slurry. 

His voice is gravel. 

His complaint is complete. 

His voice,  from the immutable edge,  is rapier sharp.

And the bitterness is deadly. 


if you REALLY want to know,  here are the facts. 

If you haven't read it.   (and if you haven't Ellison's original script for City on the Edge of Forever, how can you call yourself a Trekkie?)  here it is. 

If you like bonuses like alternate versions and endings,   here ya go. 



WARNING! 
The facts are delivered with BITE. 

The expletives and blasphemy are exactly what any Ellison reader...even the reader of but a single tale... will be expecting. 

 I didn't say "like", but you know it's coming. 


I won't bid you, "gentle reader", a good read / listen, though I doub'r you will ever forget even a single encounter with Ellison. 


I will tell you the roller-coaster has no safety belts or bars!


 I will tell you to hold on for your life!!!


THIS IS ELLISON, AND HE NEVER, EVER, HOLDS BACK. 


Anything less would not be Harlan Ellison. 

Anything less would not be worth the effort. 


This, for better and worse, is the master of wit, and edge, and words.

As salty as ever and more: Harlan Ellison.




Foofighterubu Wargame Terrain Studio

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Glad I Read It. Holly wired is Nuts

The fact that many people are included in putting together a full story that eventually ends up on the big screen is evident in most productions. It is interesting to see how an original concept is changed throughout the production process, how ego is involved, and how many people want to take credit for someone else's original idea. "The City On The Edge of Forever" my favorite Star Trek episode. In my opinion, and it is my opinion, what was eventually filmed was better than the original storyline. I did like the original concept and the original story, but I still hold that what ended up on the screen held to the Star Trek franchise and held true to the characters.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

Beter to have loved and lossed?

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

I would recommend this book to Startrek efficinato.

As I was born in 1960, you could almost say I was weened on Startrek. "The city on the edge of forever" was certainly one of my favourates, in the top five. Until now, I have never read any of the so called inside Startrek books. My thoughts were, let the stories rest on their own. I have never been the look behind the curten kind of guy. I bought and downloaded this book because I thought it was simply a version of the story adapted to audio book, guess I didn't read the description and comments.

Normally if it is Startrek, I just buy it.

Yes I have heard before that Jean Rodinbary was hard to get along with so I thought this book would be another example of the same. I guess if enough people are saying simular things, you start to think, maybe there is a fire under all that smoke.

As per the original scripts described in this book, I find myself wishing that version had been made. I don't know if it could have been done well as an hour show though. Could the additional characters been fleshed out enough? Would there have been enough time to explain the background of leveck... If not, perhaps it could have been made into a 2 part special for example. Is it possible that Jean thought that version of the story couldn't be sold tto the people that funded Startrek? Did they not want a strong character in yelman Rand? Was it not possible to put that mouch story into an hour show? Would it have required too mouch in the way of special effects than were possible at the time (1966)?

If so, why not just say so instead of this diatribe?

In any event, the book was a good read if not a pleasent one.

Alan

Who was your favorite character and why?

Hay, it's Startrek. For this episode it would have to be Edith Keyler.

What about the narrators’s performance did you like?

This book had many narrators.City on the edge of forever - extended

If you were to make a film of this book, what would the tag line be?

Knooks can be nasty too.

Any additional comments?

I guess I've said it already, I wish this version had been made.
Perhaps we want our stories to be rapped up in a neet pacage most of the time with few complecations. Once in a while it would be nice to have story archs cary on or at least referenced. Characters would matter. Stories would have more impact.

I guess those are my comments having never written a book, screen play, script not even a tiny poem, ok, maybe the aud limeric or quatrain in high school.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful