Woundhealer

Just started my experience with audible books, and really enjoyed this story. I have found that my enjoyment for this format really depends on the narrator.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Read it, don't listen

Would you try another book from Fred Saberhagen and/or Cynthia Barrett?

Cynthia Barrett ruined any hope of listening to the series within the first 30min of the book. Her narration is much like she is reading a picture book to a small child.

Would you be willing to try another one of Cynthia Barrett’s performances?

Absolutely not.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Incredible Story! Horrible Narrator!

I love the author's work! If the story hadn't been so gripping, the terrible narration would have killed it. The narrator read in a completely pedantic and menial fashion that made me feel like I was a child listening to an elementary school teacher doing a poor job at reading her class a story. She often times mispronounced names and would change them from time to time. Simply horrible! The story was great... What a shame...

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

I really enjoyed the original series. A step back

Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?

It was alright, yet definitely lacked the magic of the first series. I think part of the was a huge drop off in talent of the narrator.

If you’ve listened to books by Fred Saberhagen before, how does this one compare?

I did not enjoy it as much. The familiar characters were back and that was interesting as well as some new characters mainly the progeny of the originals. The focus on an individual sword was interesting, i suppose i was expecting more the history of the sword which i thought could have been more intriguing.

How could the performance have been better?

The original narrator from the trilogy was FAR superior.

Was Woundhealer's Story worth the listening time?

It was alright...although it did make me question rather i will buy any of the others in the series. Probably not if they feature the female narrator.

Any additional comments?

Its too bad. I really loved the originals but felt this was a step back in both performance and story.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

loved it

great book. read the book of swords first however, makes it easier to identify the characters.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Why change narrators?

Barrett reads like a preschool teacher, but Perkins was doing fantastic. Why the change?

It's especially jarring that they mispronounce the names so differently.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

narrator ruined one of my favorite books...

worse narration I have ever heard... a 90 year old with a voice box would be better

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

crap narrator

excellent story marred only by poor performance. Narrator pronounces 'cavalry' as 'calvary' and accents sentences inappropriately, jarringly implying incorrect meaning.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great story, awful reader

I listened to the original Book of Swords trilogy and really liked it. The author was great, and he did a good job with the book, the concept and the names. It is too bad that neither the reader or the producer of the Lost Swords series could not take the time to listen to those before they approached this project. The reader, Cynthia Barrett, was AWFUL. She was overly dramatic when she did not need to be, her cadence and rhythms were disconcerting. In addition, she kept mispronouncing names of characters and places. At one point, she even changed the name of one of the characters by adding an R (Amintor to Armintor). If you want to change what the author wrote, go write your own book.

I wish that I had listened to this before I bought the rest of the books, because I would not have. I have a hard time getting past her voice and style to enjoy the book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Choose Your Sword, And Step Forward Into Destiny!

Hmmm. Checking the calendar...Okay, Audible. This is quite unexpected. I've been so excited that we'd scored Saberhagen's Swords series, and I was convinced that we'd not see the Lost Swords series until after the first was completed.

But no complaining here!

This may be hard for those of you enjoying the first sword series, but this is the STRONGER of the two, as each of these book's focuses on a single sword and it's journey! Each tome is rife with high fantasy drama, rich magic, dark plot lines, nightmarish beasts, great characters and well...simply great writing.

Now, if you haven't started with Saberhagen's first swords series here at Audible, stop here and now, and go to my review of THAT series, and start there. The initial premise, concepts and details are there, and you want to start with that incredible series of audiobooks.

Okay, on to this series!

This series came about due to the sheer demand of the public, who had devoured the first series of the sword's journeys, and demanded more. A LOT more. Saberhagen gave his listeners what they wanted, and beyond.

What's so fantastic about this second series? Simple:

Audible listener, if you've read my reviews, you know that I'm extremely judicial. I demand good listens from fantasy authors. Otherwise, I am merciless when it comes to poorly-written fluff, spotted with clumsy characterizations, and weak, everyday plots.

Saberhagen delivers rich fantasy that's well worth listening.

First, Saberhagen crafts a unique fantastic literary sandbox for each sword, as he ties them all together, thus the reader will inevitably choose his or her favorite sword(s), and favorite story line(s). Rarely are they the same from reader to reader, yet each and every book is a VERY good read. When I first read the second series, I and other readers often discussed our favorites, and argued hotly why our chosen sword was better. It made for great discussions and enjoyable arguments.

Pay attention, Audible listener, THAT's the mark of a great series of books, and worthy of your reading/listening. Only when you've engaged with the author will this happen, and in this series, you'll experience that in abundance!

So, this, Woundhealer's story, is the first, and it doesn't disappoint. It lays the groundwork for the subsequent novels, and is a fantasy reader's literal trifecta: Deep magical plots that surprise, wonderful characters grafted into those plots, and rewarding action through a quality storyline. As usual, I don't dare discuss the story's details here, because it's such a good listen, that I will NOT ruin the experience with spoilers.

So, what WILL I tell you? I'll tell you this:

This book was so well conceived, so well written, so well-received by readers around the world, and Woundhealer's story so riveting and richly woven, that it spawned SEVEN other fantastic books in the series, each a phenomenal read/listen in their own unique way.

SEVEN. Yeah. I said seven.

Can you tell that I LOVE this series? I'm thinking yes.

So, now it's YOUR choice to enter a wonderful literary journey into high fantasy.

It begins. Choose your sword, and step forward into destiny!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

13 people found this helpful