Falsely Accused!

We listeners all know, right from the get-go, that poor Owen Pierce has been falsely accused of murder ... but the townsfolk don't. Given their druthers, they would lynch him for the murder of beautiful young Deborah Harrison, leaving the real killer running around free. I like it when an author uses that technique: allowing the reader to know something that none of the novel's characters -- including the protagonist -- know. Then we get to watch our hero figure out the secret. 𝘞𝑒 know that Owen Pierce didn't do it, partly because of Peter Robinson's writing skill, but also thanks to James Langton's excellent acting chops. Langton possesses the rare gift of voice. I was admiring his skill throughout this audiobook, particularly because the plot presents us with so 𝘮𝑎𝑛𝑦 different suspects. A less skilled actor could have made Owen sound as guilty as all the townsfolk think that he is. Langton clearly read "Innocent Graves" all the way through before he began recording it, so that he knew which voices to give each character -- sending exactly the right subliminal clues to us listeners.

I also liked "Innocent Graves," because it includes some intriguing courtroom scenes -- the first novel in the Alan Banks series to do so. The evidence seems stacked so profoundly high against Pierce -- and his solicitor seems so disinterested -- that we see no way for him to escape false conviction. Then his brilliant barrister (the Brits make a distinction between the lawyer that takes the case and the lawyer that argues the case) saves Pierce in court by casting reasonable doubt on all the supposed "evidence." Still, the townsfolk believe that Pierce did the murder and got away with it; so that his release puts him in grave danger of vigilante violence. Inspector Alan Banks needs to work fast to find the real killer.

Some people find that Robinson's Inspector Banks novels move too slowly, with insufficient excitement. I confess to a weakness for thrillers, myself; but I make an exception for the Inspector Banks series. Robinson's beautiful writing and Langton's masterful narration trump any problem that I might have with insufficient action. So I recommend this series to any listener with the patience to appreciate these qualities ... provided that you listen to the books in chronological order, from the beginning, starting with "Gallows View." Don't try jumping into the series in the middle -- you will miss a lot and get grumpy.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

9 people found this helpful

Skip this one

This was just poorly written and hard to follow! Skip and read the others which are fantastic.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A good "read" BUT

Would you consider the audio edition of Innocent Graves to be better than the print version?

An good story line and as usual I enjoyed Banks BUT there is so many instances of drinking and one night stands in the Banks books that is does distract from the overall story line. If you added it all up the amount of alcohol consumed makes it a cast of drunks. I was born and grew up in Scotland and we do have alcohol and alcoholics but NOT to this extent.

What other book might you compare Innocent Graves to and why?

Any of the Inspector Banks series

What about James Langton’s performance did you like?

It was O.K.

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

Thinking about drunk drivers in every chapter.

Any additional comments?

I like and read the series. I just wish it was a bit more true to life

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Hmmm

I have enjoyed all of Peter Robinson's books and even this one. It just ended abruptly so it wasn't as great as the others I have read but still very funny and engaging

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

The editor and publisher must’ve lost the last part of the book.

Maybe there was a word count maximum, or the editor and publisher dropped the last part of the book because it sure as hell wasn’t an intelligent ending! I’m getting sick of how the books just drop... just done. I want to find Peter Robinson and make him finish the damn books! Someone needs to slap the person who helped him decide that ending that way was a good idea! I’m also sick of all of them center around sex and booze. The narrator is great!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Well done!

Where does Innocent Graves rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?

I don't understand why people didn't like this book. Plot and characters were well developed. Narration was also terrific. The only down side was the rather abrupt ending. I expected a few more chapters at least!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Dropped of at the end

I'm not sure if the author just gets tired of the story near his finishing his book, or doesn't know how to close out, or even is just in a hurry due to some deadline but they seem to leave unfinished business that could be more smoothly and with a more gratifying end with an answer in regards to all his characters. I have read/listened to many of his books and think he is, as most people do, one of the top authors of our time and am not complaining about his stories overall, I've just noticed this seems to be how I feel at the end of his books and it seems so dissatisfying when the story has been so gratifying until then.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Lots of forensics and courtroom drama

Three and a half stars. I didn’t mind that this book in the series seemed to have much more forensic detail and courtroom drama than previous episodes. To some extent it was a refreshing change. But DCI Banks was so much more hardcore and abrasive this time that I didn’t find him very appealing. I hope it didn’t presage a permanent change in his character, in future books.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

The dozen or so novels I have read of his, this one I disliked.

The authors attempt at titillating narrative missed the mark, at least it didn’t improve his story in the least. I also didn’t like the ending where the author decided to put Owen in another compromising position and then left it unresolved. My impression is that he started this novel, may have left it for an extended period, changed his mind somewhere in the story, and couldn’t figure out how to resolve the characters. I won’t be rereading this one at some point in the future.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

interesting twists and turns

I loved this one. I did not see the ending coming which I appreciated.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!