it is so good

I love this series it is so worth it you will not be disappointed it is in tennis but s good!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

My favorite of the series

This has been sitting on my Kindle for a while. Honestly, after the last book I was a little nervous about reading it. This has not been my favorite series by this author…and I’ve been surprised by that because I’m a big fan of hers. But with Greg Boudreaux performing, I decided to listen to the story and I’m glad I did. This book felt more like a typical A.M. Arthur story and I’m glad for it.

I like the friends-to-lovers angle taken with these two because neither of them needed to rush into anything. Their romance was more believable with the slow build. The story was a bit predictable but it didn’t detract from the story.

There is quite a bit of angst with Miles’ ex continuing to stalk and pursue him. Reyes’ past was shocking but thankfully these guys get their HEA.

Mack and Wes as well as Colt and Avery continue to be big players in this book. We get some hints about a posible future character which I would stick around for if we get another book in the series.

As always, Mr. Boudreaux’s performance was perfection.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

I LOVE THIS SERIES!!!!!!!!!!

This series just keeps getting better. I hope that there will be more book stories in the future. At the very least we need weddings!! I am so glad we finally got Miles story. I knew something bad happened but I didn’t quite go in my mind where the story went. I am so glad that Dallas is going to get what’s coming to him. I’m hoping he’s going to be someone’s little b**** in prison. When happen with Reyes in his younger days was so heartbreaking. I can understand why he did what he did, he was in an impossible situation. These two real helped with the healing of each other. I’m so glad that the ghost town is turning into an amazing attraction and if it was a real place, I would most definitely be spending time there, as well as the ranch. I don’t know what’s up with Mack’s dad and the real reason he showed up, but I think there might be a story there. There are other things that happened in the story that happened but I can’t tell you about as it would spoil it for you. So, if you have read the other stories in this series, you need to pick this one up as soon as it’s available.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Good Read, thanks for the relaxation.

I liked this book, the emotional development and progression of the characters. The story was believable and enjoyable, I will listen to this author again. I really appreciated the way the survivors of abuse were treated in this book, it is very important to represent abuse properly and accurately Thank You.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Perfect ending to this series

Reyes and Miles are beautifully flawed. Greg is an epic narrator. Love the truth of this book, in relation to love, loss, and life in general. Thanks A.M. Arthur

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

all the stars

I loved everything I love the story I love the narrator couldn't wait to get back to it when I got pulled away from it just all the Stars

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Reyes & Miles' Story, GB is Wonderful!

When I grabbed Lucky Break off Netgalley last month I read it before I read Saddle Up. It wasn't that hard to keep up, but missing all the details about setting up the ghost town and the introduction of Shawn's character had me feeling a bit lost.

The books in AM Arthur's Clean Slate Ranch series really do build upon each other, and the characters from earlier books spend a fair bit of time in this one... I'm just saying: read them in order if you can.

So I am glad I got Reyes and Miles' story. I thought Miles was an interesting character way back from Wes' sister's wedding party, and Arthur does a great job with the past abuse issues Miles suffers from. Reyes has a terrific story as well, and the plot of Saddle Up is very well done.

As with the first two books in this series, I enjoyed it in audiobook form. The always incredible Greg Boudreaux turns in a marvelous performance, and he really does add an extra special layer to this series.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

enjoyed it

Would I listen to it again: yes ✔
Did the story keep me engaged: yes ✔
Was I invested in the characters: yes ✔

📖 Story comment: Easy pace, interesting characters and slow build romance. I liked that Reyes was respectful of Miles feelings, and that there was more story than se*y times.

🎧 Narrator comment: I love Greg Boudreaux as a narrator. Every book he narrates is a master performance. He has a good range of characters so its easy to distinguish them from each other and has a way of subtly altering his tone so it's easy to distinguish a characters inner monologue from the standard dialog which is a real skill for a narrator. He has good cadence, inflections and intonations and he really knows how to bring characters and their story to life.

------
📌 Where does it fall on my personal scale? 7
• 1 not my thing • 2 didn't like the narration • 3 didn't keep my attention • 4 was good, but once was enough • 5 enjoyed it • 6 will listen again if i'm in the mood for the narrator • 7 goes on the "re-listen" list • 8 kept me up past bed-time • 9 recommended to family/friends • 10 own it in multiple formats • 11 keep a copy with me at all times
------

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Very emotional story

This story was so emotional it really hit me hard to listen to the heartbreaking history these men had and the reasons they didn’t believe they deserved to be loved and the way Miles just couldn’t accept he needed his friends help or that he deserved help and Reyes backstory broke my heart I mean what can a scares 16 year old do when faced with that level of hate and violence this was a truly great addition to the series and look forward to continuing the journey of all the amazing characters and also narrator Greg Baudreaux is one of my favorite narrators amazing

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

It’s fine

This book is fine. There’s not much there, but it’s mostly a pleasant way to pass time by listening to it. As the 3rd in a trilogy, it’s partly extended epilogue for the previous two books. The best part of Saddle Up is seeing how the Ghost town functions. Reyes & Miles are fundamentally decent, reserved guys who like riding horses together.

Aside for trigger warnings about discussions of a former rapes and threatened rape, and some bloody noses, it’s pretty tame. They have some very careful sexual encounters that escalate carefully. I like the settings, foundations of character, activities, and friendships the author puts together. I just think they get the emotions/actions enough wrong at the climactic scenes to really throw me. I wish they were better at adding low-trauma excitement & writing climactic scenes & endings. This is the 2nd of 3 books by AM Arthur that I liked rather well for 2/3 then went “what the hell? Why are they thinking and doing those wrong things?” in the last third. It’s like going on a long pleasant stroll that ends in white water rapids.

The first third of the book is setting Miles up in his new role as ghost town chef. It’s fun. There are also threats from Miles’s ex, Dallas, and some vague mutterings from Reyes about a bad past. This book contributed to my stockpile of annoyance regarding the “I have a secret that’s super terrible but the reader can’t know it even when we have a POV character thinking about it” plot device. We get hints but the hints are askew from the issue. They don’t help; what they prepared me for was not what got revealed.

The rest of this review is all *Spoilers*, all the time.
The second third is dealing with Dallas’s threats & escalation and the ranch owner’s heart attack. There is some real content about how police don’t take stalking and sexual assault seriously enough. There’s much rushing around but nothing to seriously strain the primary relationship. This relationship is smooth sailing, all the way. They take minor stressors in stride. While this makes for a good indication of compatibility and a foundation of fundamentally being ok with each other’s quirks and needs, not much really rocked the boat. It was pleasant, but there wasn’t a lot to grab on to. It would make for a really nice comfort read except the last third goes haywire.

(Spoilers here) In the last third of the book, the police finally take the threat of Dallas seriously. Yay! BUT. It turns out Dallas has filmed himself raping Miles, so we get clips of that described. Honestly, I kept waiting for Dallas to just start posting a barrage of bad reviews of the ghost town, ranch, and saloon from multiple fake accounts which would have actually been a threat to Miles’s livelihood. But he just sends direct threats that are less bad than what an average woman gets in a month of expressing opinions on the internet. Not that the threats aren’t serious, but the author is seems out of touch with just how badly men are allowed to behave toward sexual partners. People should get hammered for these threats but they don’t. In that light Miles wanting to let it drop is reasonable but I’m glad he filed the restraining order. Still, the videos in the threats are a weird choice.

(Still spoiling away) Then with a another weird choice using a “come to Jesus” moment with a guy from his past, we find out that teenaged Reyes used to run with a gang (we knew about the gang) that did some gay bashing which escalated to gang rape. Reyes was in no position to do anything about it because his stepping in or going for help would have gotten him killed, and probably also raped. He managed not to participate and that in itself was a small miracle. It was less traumatic for him to witness the rape than to be raped but, It was trauma for him too. Unlike Dallas who hurts people repeatedly & deliberately and when called on doing harm does more harm, Reyes changes his life completely after being part of severely harming someone. By the time we meet Reyes, he’s been living his life of attempting to do good works for decades. In part to atone, in part because he discovered he really prefers to be the helper, not the bully. What I don’t get is why everyone flips out when Reyes finally, finally admits that he witnessed a gang rape that he was unable to stop. Yes, he had chosen to be with people who did that, but he got out. He turned himself into a safe person. He’s so soothing to be around that everyone should have suspected a past trauma. I get why the author thinks Miles should be freaked out by the revelation, but I don’t agree with the feelings or reasoning of the characters for getting freaked out. I just did not feel that way at all so the big reveal put me off. If Reyes had been an asshole for 20 years, Miles would never have met Reyes or stuck with him. All my sympathy was for Reyes and the blast from the past. There was literally nothing he could have done to help that victim in the moment. He could not have prevented that boy’s death. The fact that Miles helplessly, but partially in collusion with the perpetrator, witnessed a similarly traumatic death at that same age should have been overlaid in the processing and it was not. There was no other reason for that backstory car accident. Miles could have acted out in some other way and had some other reason to stop acting out or not, still gone to college and still have been prey for Dallas without that car wreck, so why is it there if not to give him sympathy for Reyes’s younger self? That Reyes also turned his life around for good is more important.

(Still spoiling) The unnecessary moment of moral panic did distract me from realizing Reyes never really processes his lack ability to be superman in the rookie’s fire death either. He does eventually show Miles his physical scars and that is a proxy for moving past it but it mostly just gets dropped. Basically, Reyes became a good person who tries to be a safe person to be around and largely succeeds. He’s a good guy, I wish the characters well. But his emotional arc was badly done.

(Spoilers here) I am also put out by Miles getting praise for his *success* at fighting off Dallas rather than praise for his *attempt* to fight off Dallas and relief that the result mostly came out in Miles’s favor. The scene struck me as a weird mix of taking some wrong actions for some wrong reasons mixed in with good actions. “Sticking up for yourself” doesn’t always mean being confrontational and egging an abuser into escalation. Miles could have chosen safer things to say and do and *still* have been successful, and possibly with less damage to himself, in sticking up for himself. There was a soupçon too much toxic masculinity in how he defined “standing up for himself” and it rubbed me wrong when I wanted to cheer him on. I was thinking “Don’t taunt the guy holding you at gunpoint, idiot!” not “Way to go!” in the moment.

People who think the way the author does about the varied events will probably like this book just fine. But for me, the author keeps snatching emotional defeat from the jaws of victory in the home stretch. I checked my progress and when, at 1.25X speed, there was 4 hours of story left, I was basically sold on the cosy low key romance. It could have easily ended there and been a nice little story. I was rightly leery of where it went.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

13 people found this helpful